Below is a list of the 440 members of the BBWAA who cast ballots in the 2016 Hall of Fame election. A list of ballots voters submitted for publication are here. For more on voting eligibility, see our Voting FAQ.
| Peter Abraham | Phil Elderkin | George King | Philip Pepe |
| Bill Abramson | Bob Elliott | Mark Kiszla | Dave Perkins |
| Dave Albee | Chris Ellsberry | Bob Klapisch | John Perrotto |
| Bucky Albers | John Erardi | Mike Klis | Mike Peticca |
| Jim Alexander | Gerald Eskenazi | Chuck Klonke | Ed Petruska |
| Edward Almada | Alan Eskew | Michael Knisley | Nick Pietruszkiewicz |
| John Altavilla | Jack Etkin | Danny Knobler | Rick Plumlee |
| David Ammenheuser | Mark Faller | Nobuyuki Kobayashi | Bill Plunkett |
| Dom Amore | R.B. Fallstrom | Keizo Konishi | Terry Pluto |
| Mel Antonen | John Fay | Steve Kornacki | George Pohly |
| Jim Armstrong | Howard Fendrich | Dejan Kovacevic | Steve Politi |
| Kirby Arnold | Martin Fennelly | Steven Krasner | Monte Poole |
| Jaime Aron | Vic Feuerherd | Mark Kreidler | Steve Popper |
| Chris Assenheimer | Ken Fidlin | Dave Krieger | Joe Posnanski |
| Paul Attner | Mike Fine | Ron Kroichick | Scott Priestle |
| Andrew Baggarly | Bob Finnigan | Roch Kubatko | Mike Puma |
| Chris Bahr | Mike Fitzpatrick | Robert Kuenster | Mark Purdy |
| Geoff Baker | Jeffrey Flanagan | Tim Kurkjian | Rob Rains |
| Kent Baker | Jeff Fletcher | John Labombarda | Ron Rapoport |
| Bill Ballou | Carlos Frias | Gabe Lacques | Ray Ratto |
| Craig Barnes | Barry Fritz | Pierre Ladoueur | Troy Renck |
| David Barron | Carter Gaddis | Larry Lage | Pat Reusse |
| Peter Barzilai | Tom Gage | Keith Lair | David Reynolds |
| Mike Bass | Greg Gallo | Marc Lancaster | Tim Reynolds |
| Bob Baum | Randy Galloway | Bill Lankhof | Anthony Rieber |
| Michael Bauman | Peter Gammons | Dave Lariviere | Tracy Ringolsby |
| Greg Beacham | James Gauger | Scott Lauber | Brendan Roberts |
| Amalie Benjamin | Dan Gelston | Gil LeBreton | Alan Robinson |
| Mike Berardino | Dennis Georgatos | Mike Lefkow | Joseph Roderick |
| Robert Biertempfel | Joe Gergen | David Lennon | Carroll Rogers |
| Steve Bisheff | Greg Gibson | Bernard Lincicome | Phil Rogers |
| John Black | Steven Gietschier | Bill Livingston | Jorge Rojas |
| Fran Blinebury | Robert Gillies | Seth Livingstone | C. Trent Rosecrans |
| Barry Bloom | Toni Ginnetti | John Lopez | Bob Rosen |
| Earl Bloom | Dave Ginsburg | Mike Lopresti | Ken Rosenthal |
| Ron Blum | Brian Golden | Thom Loverro | John Rowe |
| Paul Bodi | Steve Goldman | John Lowe | Barry Rozner |
| Hal Bodley | Jimmy Golen | Ruben Luna | Adam Rubin |
| Filip Bondy | Pedro Gomez | Mike Lupica | Roger Rubin |
| Scott Bordow | Mark Gonzales | Rob Maaddi | Richard Rupprecht |
| David Borges | Derrick Goold | Bill Madden | Joe Rutter |
| Patrick Borzi | Cormac Gordon | John Maffei | Robert Ryan |
| Don Bostrom | Rick Gosselin | Dennis Maffezzoli | Tom Saladino |
| Peter Botte | Evan Grant | Jack Magruder | Bob Sansevere |
| Mark Bradley | Dan Graziano | Mark Maloney | Mark Saxon |
| Stephen Bray | Jerry Green | Dennis Manoloff | dick scanlon |
| Marcos Breton | Jay Greenberg | Steven Marcus | Mark Schmetzer |
| Larry Brooks | Alan Greenwood | David Maril | Henry Schulman |
| Garry Brown | Scot Gregor | Art Martone | Jeff Schultz |
| Howard Bryant | Richard Griffin | Tony Massarotti | Glenn Schwarz |
| Ray Buck | Karen Guregian | Jim Massie | Charles Scoggins |
| Steve Buckley | Paul Gutierrez | Wallace Matthews | Mike Shalin |
| Don Burke | Joe Haakenson | Warren Mayes | Drew Sharp |
| David Bush | Chris Haft | Sean McAdam | Dan Shaughnessy |
| Nick Cafardo | Paul Hagen | Jack McCaffery | John Shea |
| Peter Caldera | Mark Hale | Anthony McCarron | Susan Shemanski |
| Andrew Call | John Harper | Janie McCauley | Joel Sherman |
| Dave Campbell | Beth Harris | Sean McClelland | Bob Sherwin |
| Nick Canepa | Bill Hartman | Hal McCoy | Michael Silverman |
| John Canzano | Sid Hartman | Dan McGrath | Steve Simmons |
| Jim Caple | Tom Haudricourt | John McGrath | Corky Simpson |
| Joe Capozzi | Jim Hawkins | Len Megliola | Howard Siner |
| Pat Caputo | Stephen Hawkins | Adam Mertz | Tom Singer |
| Sam Carchidi | Joe Henderson | Paul Meyer | Seymour Siwoff |
| Rene Cardenas | Cathy Henkel | Bernie Miklasz | Dave Sloan |
| Les Carpenter | Jim Henneman | Bruce Miles | Susan Slusser |
| John Carson | Steve Henson | Jeff Miller | Claire Smith |
| Bill Center | Manolo Hernandez-Douen | Randy Miller | Bob Smizik |
| Murray Chass | Steve Herrick | Scott Miller | Lyle Spencer |
| Ron Chimelis | Mark Herrmann | Larry Millson | Barry Stanton |
| Joe Christensen | Bob Hertzel | Fred Mitchell | Arnie Stapleton |
| Tom Christensen | Bob Herzog | Jim Molony | Jayson Stark |
| Frank Clines | Roy Hewitt | Roger Mooney | Alex Stern |
| Bob Cohn | Brian Heyman | Terence Moore | Carl Steward |
| Lowell Cohn | Jon Heyman | Malcolm Moran | Christopher Stier |
| Gene Collier | John Hickey | Aurelio Moreno | Larry Stone |
| Roberto Colon | Hirokazu Higuchi | Jon Paul Morosi | Jim Street |
| Dan Connolly | Ed Hilt | Rick Morrissey | Paul Sullivan |
| Ron Cook | Ken Hirdt | Irv Moss | TR Sullivan |
| Kevin Cooney | Peter Hirdt | Chuck Murr | Gaku Tashiro |
| Brian Costello | Steve Hirdt | Carrie Muskat | Rick Telander |
| Greg Cote | Tom Hirdt | Gene Myers | John Tomase |
| Joe Cowley | Bob Hohler | John Nadel | Marc Topkin |
| Tim Cowlishaw | Joseph Hoppel | Mike Nadel | Douglas Tucker |
| Jerry Crasnick | Jeff Horrigan | La Velle Neal III | Howard Ulman |
| Glen Crevier | Alan Hoskins | Paul Newberry | Mike Vaccaro |
| Jack Curry | Garry D. Howard | Ross Newhan | Dave van Dyck |
| Guy Curtright | Johnette Howard | Mark Newman | George Vass |
| Tim Dahlberg | Paul Hoynes | Bob Nightengale | Juan Vene |
| Tom D'Angelo | David Hughes | Marty Noble | Rick Ventura |
| Dave Daniel | Rick Hummel | Eric Nunez | Tom Verducci |
| Paul Daugherty | Michael Hunt | Sheldon Ocker | Constantino Viloria |
| Shi Davidi | Barney Hutchinson | Jack O'Connell | Jeff Vorva |
| Ken Davidoff | Gary Hyvonen | Ian O'Connor | Mike Waldner |
| Art Davidson | Mike Imrem | Charles Odum | James Walker |
| John Delcos | Jim Ingraham | Hideki Okuda | Charley Walters |
| Chris DeLuca | Jeff Jacobs | Drew Olson | Bob Waterman |
| Tony DeMarco | Steve Jacobson | Shaun O'Neill | Mark Whicker |
| Tom Dienhart | Bruce Jenkins | Jorge Ortiz | Paul White |
| Vinny DiTrani | Chuck Johnson | Jose de Jesus Ortiz | David Wilhelm |
| Mike Dodd | Joey Johnston | Joe Ostermeier | Jack Wilkinson |
| Bob Dolgan | Richard Justice | Bob Padecky | George Willis |
| Mike Downey | Dick Kaegel | Doug Padilla | Bernie Wilson |
| Paul Doyle | Marc Katz | Jill Painter | Bill Windler |
| Josh Dubow | Tim Kawakami | Lawrence Pantages | Steve Wine |
| Jay Dunn | Joe Kay | Robert Parker | Gordon Wittenmyer |
| Bob Dutton | Tom Keegan | Peter Pascarelli | Gregg Wong |
| Chuck Dybdal | Peter Kerasotis | Jeffrey Passan | Akiko Yamawaki |
| Jorge Ebro | Kevin Kernan | Gregg Patton | Tom Yantz |
| John Eisenberg | Ann Killion | Jeff Peek | Mark Zuckerman |