Tim Lincecum of the San Francisco Giants was elected the National League Cy Young Award winner for the second consecutive year in balloting by the BBWAA. Lincecum had the lowest victory total over a full season of any starting pitcher who won the award in either league.
The previous low victory total for a Cy Young Award-winning starter in a season not affected by a strike was by Brandon Webb, who was 16-8 for the Arizona Diamondbacks in 2006. It was matched Tuesday by 2009 American League winner Zack Greinke, who was 16-8 for the Kansas City Royals.
The election also marked only the second time that a pitcher won the award without receiving the most first-place votes. Of the 32 ballots submitted by two writers in each league city, Lincecum (15-7, 2.48 ERA) was listed first on 11, one fewer than the St. Louis Cardinals’ Adam Wainwright (19-8, 2.63 ERA), who finished third overall behind teammate Chris Carpenter (17-4, 2.24 ERA), the 2005 winner.
Lincecum was named second on 12 ballots and third on nine for a total of 100 points, based on a 5-3-1 tabulation system. In addition to his 12 first-place votes, Wainwright got five seconds and 15 thirds to score 90 points. Lincecum and Wainwright were the only pitchers on all ballots. Carpenter was first on nine ballots, second on 14 and third on seven for 94 points.
The only other time a pitcher won the Cy Young Award without the most first-place votes was in 1998 when the Atlanta Braves’ Tom Glavine had 11 to San Diego Padres reliever Trevor Hoffman’s 13 but out-pointed him overall, 98-88.
The six-point margin was tied for the third closest election in the NL since the ballot expanded from one to three pitchers in 1970. The 10-point margin among the top three vote getters was the second closest in NL voting. In 1987, Philadelphia Phillies reliever Steve Bedrosian beat out the Chicago Cubs’ Rick Sutcliffe, 57-55, with Rick Reuschel, who pitched for both the Pittsburgh Pirates and San Francisco Giants that year, running a close third with 54 points.
The second closest 1-2 election was in 1981 with the Los Angeles Dodgers’ Fernando Valenzuela defeating the Cincinnati Reds’ Tom Seaver, 70-67. This year’s election equals that of 1979 when the Cubs’ Bruce Sutter edged the Houston Astros’ Joe Niekro, 72-66.
Lincecum, one of only two Giants pitchers honored (left-hander Mike McCormick won in 1967), led the NL in strikeouts with 261 in 225 1/3 innings and was tied for the league lead in complete games (4) and shutouts (2). Carpenter led the league in ERA and winning percentage (.810). Wainwright topped the NL in victories and innings (233).
Greg Maddux and Randy Johnson share the record for consecutive Cy Young victories with four. As a repeat winner, Lincecum also joins Sandy Koufax (1965-66) in the NL. AL repeat winners were Roger Clemens, who did it twice (1986-87, 1997-98), Denny McLain (1968-69), Jim Palmer (1975-76) and Pedro Martinez (1999-2000).
2009 NL Cy Young
|Tim Lincecum, San Francisco Giants||11||12||9||100|
|Chris Carpenter, St. Louis Cardinals||9||14||7||94|
|Adam Wainwright, St. Louis Cardinals||12||5||15||90|
|Javier Vazquez, Atlanta Braves||1||3|
|Dan Haren, Arizona Diamondbacks||1||1|
Below is a breakdown of the 32 individual ballots, submitted by two writers representing each city in the National League. For more information on the voting, see our Voting FAQ.
|Guy Curtright||At Large, Atlanta||Wainwright||Carpenter||Lincecum|
|Manny Navarro||Miami Herald||Carpenter||Lincecum||Wainwright|
|Steve Popper||Bergen Record||Lincecum||Carpenter||Wainwright|
|Jim Salisbury||Philadelphia Inquirer||Wainwright||Lincecum||Carpenter|
|Ken Rosenthal||FOX Sports.com||Wainwright||Lincecum||Carpenter|
|Mark Zuckerman||Washington Times||Wainwright||Carpenter||Lincecum|
|Paul Sullivan||Chicago Tribune||Lincecum||Wainwright||Carpenter|
|Toni Ginnetti||Chicago Sun Times||Wainwright||Lincecum||Carpenter|
|Will Carroll||Baseball Prospectus||Wainwright||Lincecum||Haren|
|Tom Groeschen||Cincinnati Enquirer||Lincecum||Carpenter||Wainwright|
|Bill Madden||New York Daily News||Wainwright||Lincecum||Carpenter|
|Zachary Levine||Houston Chronicle||Carpenter||Lincecum||Wainwright|
|Susan Shemanske||Racine Journal Times||Carpenter||Wainwright||Lincecum|
|Dennis Semrau||Madison Capital Times||Lincecum||Carpenter||Wainwright|
|John Perrotto||Ogden Newspapers||Lincecum||Carpenter||Wainwright|
|Chuck Finder||Pittsburgh Post Gazette||Carpenter||Lincecum||Wainwright|
|Derrick Goold||St. Louis Post Dispatch||Wainwright||Carpenter||Lincecum|
|Bernie Miklasz||St. Louis Post Dispatch||Carpenter||Wainwright||Lincecum|
|Nick Piecoro||Arizona Republic||Lincecum||Wainwright||Carpenter|
|Sarah Trotto||Arizona Daily Star||Lincecum||Carpenter||Wainwright|
|Jack Etkin||At Large, Denver||Carpenter||Lincecum||Wainwright|
|Patrick Saunders||Denver Post||Wainwright||Carpenter||Lincecum|
|Doug Padilla||L.A. Newspaper Group||Carpenter||Lincecum||Wainwright|
|Randy Youngman||Orange County Register||Wainwright||Carpenter||Lincecum|
|Scott Miller||CBS Sports.com||Lincecum||Carpenter||Wainwright|
|Chris Jenkins||San Diego Union Tribune||Wainwright||Carpenter||Lincecum|
|Paul Gutierrez||Sacramento Bee||Carpenter||Lincecum||Wainwright|
|Henry Schulman||San Francisco Chronicle||Carpenter||Lincecum||Wainwright|