Below is a breakdown of the 30 individual ballots, submitted by two writers representing each city in the National League. For more information on the voting, see our Voting FAQ.
| Name | Affiliation | Chapter | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th | 6th | 7th | 8th | 9th | 10th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gabriel Burns | The Atlanta Journal-Constitution | ATL | Bellinger | Yelich | Rendon | Marte | Freeman | Acuña | Arenado | Alonso | Soto | DeGrom |
| Mark Bowman | MLB.com | ATL | Yelich | Bellinger | Rendon | Marte | Freeman | Acuña | Arenado | Alonso | Soto | Donaldson |
| Robert Nightengale | USA TODAY | AZ | Bellinger | Rendon | Yelich | Freeman | Acuña | Alonso | Marte | Arenado | Soto | Flaherty |
| Zach Buchanan | The Athletic | AZ | Bellinger | Yelich | Marte | Rendon | Arenado | Story | Acuña | Muncy | Soto | Alonso |
| Jordan Bastian | MLB.com | CHI | Yelich | Bellinger | Rendon | Marte | Acuña | Arenado | Alonso | Soto | Story | Realmuto |
| Sahadev Sharma | The Athletic | CHI | Yelich | Bellinger | Rendon | Marte | Acuña | DeGrom | Arenado | Donaldson | Alonso | Story |
| Mark Sheldon | MLB.com | CIN | Yelich | Bellinger | Rendon | Acuña | Freeman | Marte | Arenado | Alonso | Soto | Suarez |
| Bobby Nightengale | Cincinnati Enquirer | CIN | Bellinger | Yelich | Rendon | Acuña | Marte | Freeman | Arenado | Alonso | Soto | Wong |
| Patrick Saunders | The Denver Post | COL | Bellinger | Yelich | Acuña | Arenado | Rendon | Marte | Freeman | Soto | Alonso | Realmuto |
| Tracy Ringolsby | InsideTheSeams.com | COL | Rendon | Freeman | Arenado | Yelich | Bellinger | Marte | Acuña | Alonso | DeGrom | Soto |
| J.P. Hoornstra | Southern California News Group | LA | Bellinger | Yelich | Rendon | Marte | Arenado | Acuña | Alonso | Soto | Grandal | Freeman |
| Tim Brown | Yahoo Sports | LA | Bellinger | Yelich | Rendon | Marte | Arenado | Story | Acuña | Alonso | DeGrom | Soto |
| Steven Wine | Associated Press | MIA | Bellinger | Yelich | Rendon | Marte | Acuña | Alonso | Donaldson | Story | Arenado | Suarez |
| Andre Fernandez | The Athletic | MIA | Yelich | Bellinger | Rendon | Marte | Acuña | Arenado | Flaherty | Alonso | DeGrom | Suarez |
| Todd Rosiak | Milwaukee Journal Sentinel | MIL | Yelich | Bellinger | Rendon | Marte | DeGrom | Acuña | Arenado | Strasburg | Story | Scherzer |
| Adam McCalvy | MLB.com | MIL | Yelich | Bellinger | Rendon | Marte | Arenado | Acuña | Donaldson | Alonso | Soto | Story |
| Anthony DiComo | MLB.com | NY | Bellinger | Yelich | Rendon | Marte | Alonso | Soto | Acuña | Arenado | Freeman | Suarez |
| Tim Britton | The Athletic | NY | Bellinger | Yelich | Rendon | Marte | DeGrom | Acuña | Alonso | Ryu | Freeman | Soto |
| Jayson Stark | The Athletic | PHI | Yelich | Bellinger | Rendon | Acuña | Marte | Alonso | Freeman | DeGrom | Arenado | Donaldson |
| Jim Salisbury | NBC Sports Philadelphia | PHI | Bellinger | Yelich | Rendon | Freeman | Marte | Acuña | Donaldson | Soto | Goldschmidt | Alonso |
| Adam Berry | MLB.com | PIT | Bellinger | Yelich | Rendon | Marte | Arenado | Acuña | DeGrom | Alonso | Grandal | Donaldson |
| Rob Biertempfel | The Athletic | PIT | Yelich | Bellinger | Rendon | Marte | Acuña | Arenado | Alonso | Realmuto | Freeman | Soto |
| Kevin Acee | San Diego Union-Tribune | SD | Bellinger | Yelich | Rendon | Marte | DeGrom | Donaldson | Alonso | Story | Acuña | Strasburg |
| Scott Miller | Bleacher Report | SD | Bellinger | Yelich | Rendon | Marte | Acuña | Alonso | Arenado | Freeman | Soto | Wong |
| Alex Pavlovic | NBC Sports Bay Area | SF | Bellinger | Yelich | Marte | Rendon | Arenado | Acuña | Alonso | Realmuto | Donaldson | Muncy |
| Henry Schulman | San Francisco Chronicle | SF | Bellinger | Yelich | Rendon | Marte | Freeman | Alonso | Arenado | Soto | Acuña | Pillar |
| Derrick Goold | St. Louis Post-Dispatch | STL | Bellinger | Yelich | Rendon | Marte | DeGrom | Freeman | Arenado | Flaherty | Alonso | Acuña |
| Rick Hummel | St. Louis Post-Dispatch | STL | Yelich | Bellinger | Marte | Rendon | Freeman | Arenado | Acuña | Alonso | Soto | Flaherty |
| Tim Kurkjian | ESPN | WAS | Bellinger | Yelich | Rendon | Acuña | Alonso | Marte | Freeman | Soto | Donaldson | Arenado |
| Brittany Ghiroli | The Athletic | WAS | Bellinger | Yelich | Rendon | Acuña | Marte | Freeman | Story | Alonso | Arenado | DeGrom |