Below is a breakdown of the 30 individual ballots, submitted by two writers representing each city in the American League. For more information on the voting, see our Voting FAQ.
| Name | Affiliation | Chapter | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th | 6th | 7th | 8th | 9th | 10th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tim Kurkjian | ESPN | BAL | Ohtani | Seager | Tucker | Semien | Rodríguez | Díaz | Henderson | Ramírez | Rutschman | Bichette |
| Rich Dubroff | BaltimoreBaseball.com | BAL | Ohtani | Seager | Díaz | Semien | Rodríguez | Henderson | Tucker | Witt | Robert Jr. | Alvarez |
| Jen McCaffrey | The Athletic | BOS | Ohtani | Seager | Rodríguez | Semien | Tucker | Díaz | Rutschman | Robert Jr. | Henderson | Ramírez |
| Alex Speier | Boston Globe | BOS | Ohtani | Seager | Rodríguez | Semien | Tucker | Díaz | Witt | Rutschman | Judge | Alvarez |
| Scot Gregor | Daily Herald | CHI | Ohtani | Seager | Rodríguez | Semien | Tucker | Díaz | Witt | Henderson | Robert Jr. | Ramírez |
| Vinnie Duber | CHGO | CHI | Ohtani | Seager | Semien | Witt | Rodríguez | Robert Jr. | Tucker | Rutschman | Ramírez | Díaz |
| Zack Meisel | The Athletic | CLE | Ohtani | Seager | Díaz | Semien | Tucker | Rodríguez | Rutschman | Ramírez | Robert Jr. | Witt |
| Paul Hoynes | Cleveland.com | CLE | Ohtani | Semien | Seager | Tucker | Rodríguez | Witt | Henderson | Alvarez | Devers | Naylor |
| Evan Woodbery | MLive Media Group | DET | Ohtani | Tucker | Seager | Semien | Rodríguez | Díaz | Ramírez | Rutschman | Witt | Bregman |
| Chris McCosky | Detroit News | DET | Ohtani | Seager | Díaz | Tucker | Rodríguez | Alvarez | Semien | García | Henderson | Witt |
| Brian McTaggart | MLB.com | HOU | Ohtani | Semien | Seager | Rodríguez | Tucker | Alvarez | Díaz | Witt | Judge | Crawford |
| Tom Verducci | SI.com | HOU | Ohtani | Seager | Rodríguez | Semien | Tucker | Díaz | Henderson | Witt | Ramírez | Cole |
| Pete Grathoff | Kansas City Star | KC | Ohtani | Seager | Rodríguez | Semien | Tucker | Díaz | Ramírez | Henderson | Witt | Alvarez |
| Dave Skretta | The Associated Press | KC | Ohtani | Seager | Rodríguez | Semien | Witt | García | Ramírez | Robert Jr. | Bichette | Rutschman |
| Nobuhiro Saito | Nikkan Sports News | LA | Ohtani | Seager | Tucker | Cole | Semien | Rodríguez | García | Witt | Díaz | Robert Jr. |
| Rhett Bollinger | MLB.com | LA | Ohtani | Seager | Semien | Rodríguez | Witt | Tucker | Cole | Henderson | Díaz | Gray |
| Dave Campbell | Associated Press | MIN | Ohtani | Seager | Tucker | Rodríguez | Semien | Henderson | Díaz | Witt | Raleigh | Robert Jr. |
| Aaron Gleeman | The Athletic | MIN | Ohtani | Seager | Rodríguez | Semien | Cole | Tucker | Díaz | Henderson | Ramírez | Crawford |
| Pete Caldera | Bergen Record | NY | Ohtani | Semien | Seager | Díaz | Henderson | Tucker | Rodríguez | Cole | Rutschman | Gray |
| Erik Boland | Newsday | NY | Ohtani | Seager | Rodríguez | Tucker | Semien | Díaz | Rutschman | Judge | Paredes | Henderson |
| John Shea | San Francisco Chronicle | OAK | Ohtani | Semien | Seager | Tucker | Henderson | Díaz | Rodríguez | Ramírez | Rutschman | Witt |
| Martín Gallegos | MLB.com | OAK | Ohtani | Semien | Seager | Rodríguez | Witt | Tucker | Rutschman | Díaz | Ramírez | Henderson |
| Ryan Divish | Seattle Times | SEA | Ohtani | Seager | Semien | Rodríguez | Henderson | Tucker | Díaz | Witt | Cole | Crawford |
| Larry Stone | Seattle Times | SEA | Ohtani | Seager | Semien | Rodríguez | Díaz | Tucker | Henderson | Witt | Crawford | Cole |
| Marc Topkin | Tampa Bay Times | TB | Ohtani | Seager | Díaz | Rodríguez | Tucker | Rutschman | Semien | Ramírez | Bichette | Witt |
| Adam Berry | MLB.com | TB | Ohtani | Seager | Semien | Rodríguez | Díaz | Tucker | Witt | Henderson | Ramírez | Rutschman |
| Evan Grant | Dallas Morning News | TEX | Ohtani | Seager | Tucker | Rodríguez | Henderson | Díaz | Semien | Witt | Robert Jr. | Rutschman |
| Kennedi Landry | MLB.com | TEX | Ohtani | Seager | Semien | Tucker | Díaz | Rodríguez | Cole | Henderson | Witt | Rutschman |
| Ian Harrison | Associated Press | TOR | Ohtani | Seager | Semien | Rutschman | Tucker | Díaz | Rodríguez | Henderson | García | Witt |
| Keegan Matheson | MLB.com | TOR | Ohtani | Seager | Semien | Rodríguez | Witt | Tucker | Ramírez | Rutschman | Cole | Díaz |