Below is a breakdown of the 30 individual ballots, submitted by two writers representing each city in the American League. For more information on the voting, see our Voting FAQ.
| Name | Affiliation | Chapter | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th | 6th | 7th | 8th | 9th | 10th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jake Rill | MLB.com | BAL | Judge | Witt | Henderson | Soto | Ramírez | Duran | Skubal | Guerrero | Alvarez | Rooker |
| Ken Rosenthal | The Athletic | BAL | Judge | Witt | Henderson | Soto | Ramírez | Alvarez | Clase | Skubal | Duran | Guerrero |
| Christopher Smith | MassLive.com | BOS | Judge | Witt | Soto | Henderson | Ramírez | Skubal | Duran | Alvarez | Guerrero | Rooker |
| Rob Bradford | WEEI.com | BOS | Judge | Witt | Soto | Henderson | Ramírez | Guerrero | Duran | Alvarez | Rooker | Skubal |
| James Fegan | At-Large | CHI | Judge | Witt | Henderson | Soto | Ramírez | Duran | Skubal | Guerrero | Raleigh | Rooker |
| Jesse Rogers | ESPN | CHI | Judge | Witt | Soto | Henderson | Alvarez | Ramírez | Clase | Santander | Skubal | Guerrero |
| Paul Hoynes | cleveland.com | CLE | Judge | Witt | Ramírez | Soto | Henderson | Alvarez | Clase | Guerrero | Duran | Santander |
| Zack Meisel | The Athletic | CLE | Judge | Witt | Soto | Henderson | Ramírez | Duran | Guerrero | Alvarez | Rooker | Devers |
| Jason Beck | MLB.com | DET | Judge | Witt | Soto | Henderson | Ramírez | Skubal | Alvarez | Duran | Guerrero | Rooker |
| Jon Paul Morosi | MLB.com | DET | Judge | Witt | Henderson | Soto | Ramírez | Skubal | Clase | Duran | Guerrero | Alvarez |
| Jesus Ortiz | Our Esquina | HOU | Judge | Witt | Soto | Henderson | Ramírez | Alvarez | Skubal | Duran | Guerrero | Valdez |
| Richard Justice | Texas Monthly | HOU | Judge | Witt | Soto | Henderson | Ramírez | Alvarez | Guerrero | Rooker | Duran | Skubal |
| Anne Rogers | MLB.com | KC | Judge | Witt | Soto | Henderson | Guerrero | Ramírez | Skubal | Duran | Clase | Rooker |
| Sam McDowell | The Kansas City Star | KC | Judge | Witt | Soto | Henderson | Ramírez | Skubal | Guerrero | Duran | Rooker | Clase |
| Sam Blum | The Athletic | LA | Judge | Witt | Soto | Ramírez | Henderson | Skubal | Guerrero | Clase | Rooker | Lugo |
| Jeff Fletcher | Orange County Register | LA | Judge | Witt | Soto | Henderson | Alvarez | Guerrero | Ramírez | Rooker | Skubal | Duran |
| Betsy Helfand | St. Paul Pioneer Press | MIN | Judge | Witt | Soto | Henderson | Ramírez | Skubal | Duran | Clase | Guerrero | Alvarez |
| Bobby Nightengale | Minnesota Star Tribune | MIN | Judge | Witt | Soto | Ramírez | Henderson | Guerrero | Alvarez | Duran | Clase | Skubal |
| Joel Sherman | New York Post | NY | Judge | Witt | Henderson | Ramírez | Soto | Duran | Skubal | Clase | Alvarez | Guerrero |
| Tom Verducci | SI.com | NY | Judge | Witt | Soto | Henderson | Ramírez | Guerrero | Skubal | Duran | Alvarez | Rooker |
| Janie McCauley | Associated Press | OAK | Judge | Witt | Ramírez | Soto | Henderson | Guerrero | Devers | Duran | Rooker | Altuve |
| Eno Sarris | The Athletic | OAK | Judge | Witt | Soto | Henderson | Guerrero | Ramírez | Duran | Alvarez | Rooker | Raleigh |
| Daniel Kramer | MLB.com | SEA | Judge | Witt | Soto | Ramírez | Henderson | Duran | Rooker | Raleigh | Guerrero | Alvarez |
| Adam Jude | The Seattle Times | SEA | Judge | Witt | Soto | Ramírez | Henderson | Skubal | Raleigh | Alvarez | Guerrero | Rooker |
| Marc Topkin | Tampa Bay Times | TB | Judge | Witt | Soto | Henderson | Ramírez | Skubal | Alvarez | Guerrero | Rooker | Clase |
| Adam Berry | MLB.com | TB | Judge | Witt | Soto | Henderson | Ramírez | Skubal | Guerrero | Duran | Rooker | Clase |
| Levi Weaver | The Athletic | TEX | Judge | Witt | Soto | Skubal | Henderson | Ramírez | Duran | Rooker | Alvarez | Seager |
| Shawn McFarland | The Dallas Morning News | TEX | Judge | Witt | Henderson | Duran | Soto | Ramírez | Skubal | Guerrero | Rooker | Alvarez |
| Mike Wilner | Toronto Star | TOR | Judge | Witt | Ramírez | Soto | Henderson | Guerrero | Clase | Alvarez | Rooker | Holton |
| Ben Nicholson-Smith | Sportsnet | TOR | Judge | Witt | Soto | Henderson | Ramírez | Guerrero | Duran | Skubal | Raleigh | Alvarez |