Below is a breakdown of the 30 individual ballots, submitted by two writers representing each city in the American League. For more information on the voting, see our Voting FAQ.
| Name | Affiliation | Chapter | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th | 6th | 7th | 8th | 9th | 10th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Danielle Allentuck | The Baltimore Banner | BAL | Raleigh | Judge | Witt Jr. | Skubal | Ramírez | Crochet | Springer | Rodríguez | Peña | Kurtz |
| Britt Ghiroli | The Athletic | BAL | Raleigh | Judge | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Skubal | Crochet | Rodríguez | Springer | Garcia | Caminero |
| Ian Browne | MLB.com | BOS | Raleigh | Judge | Witt Jr. | Rodríguez | Ramírez | Springer | Skubal | Caminero | Crochet | Buxton |
| Peter Abraham | Boston Globe | BOS | Judge | Raleigh | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Springer | Skubal | Crochet | Rodríguez | Caminero | Peña |
| LaMond Pope | Chicago Tribune | CHI | Judge | Raleigh | Witt Jr. | Skubal | Ramírez | Rodríguez | Springer | Buxton | Crochet | Peña |
| Scott Merkin | MLB.com | CHI | Judge | Raleigh | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Skubal | Crochet | Rodríguez | Springer | Caminero | Buxton |
| Zack Meisel | The Athletic | CLE | Judge | Raleigh | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Springer | Guerrero Jr. | Caminero | Rodríguez | Garcia | Díaz |
| Paul Hoynes | Cleveland.com/The Plain Dealer | CLE | Raleigh | Judge | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Kurtz | Rodríguez | Bellinger | Bichette | Greene | Caminero |
| Evan Petzold | Detroit Free Press | DET | Judge | Raleigh | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Skubal | Springer | Rodríguez | Crochet | Peña | Buxton |
| Chris McCosky | Detroit News | DET | Raleigh | Judge | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Springer | Rodríguez | Caminero | Buxton | Guerrero Jr. | Peña |
| Javier Gonzalez | Pelota Cubana USA | HOU | Judge | Raleigh | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Springer | Rodríguez | Skubal | Peña | Buxton | Caminero |
| Chandler Rome | The Athletic | HOU | Judge | Raleigh | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Rodríguez | Springer | Buxton | Skubal | Garcia | Kurtz |
| Jaylon Thompson | Kansas City Star | KC | Raleigh | Judge | Witt Jr. | Ramírez | Springer | Skubal | Caminero | Kurtz | Bichette | Greene |
| Joe Posnanski | JoeBlogs | KC | Judge | Raleigh | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Rodríguez | Skubal | Crochet | Peña | Springer | Kurtz |
| Mike DiGiovanna | BBWAA (At-Large) | LA | Raleigh | Judge | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Springer | Skubal | Rodríguez | Crochet | Guerrero Jr. | Kurtz |
| Rhett Bollinger | MLB.com | LA | Raleigh | Judge | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Skubal | Rodríguez | Crochet | Springer | Guerrero Jr. | Peña |
| Betsy Helfand | St. Paul Pioneer Press | MIN | Judge | Raleigh | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Rodríguez | Springer | Buxton | Skubal | Crochet | Peña |
| Phil Miller | Minnesota Star Tribune | MIN | Judge | Raleigh | Witt Jr. | Ramírez | Rodríguez | Skubal | Buxton | Springer | Kurtz | Bellinger |
| Tyler Kepner | The Athletic | NY | Raleigh | Judge | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Crochet | Springer | Skubal | Rodríguez | Bellinger | Chapman |
| Ronald Blum | The Associated Press | NY | Judge | Raleigh | Skubal | Witt Jr. | Ramírez | Springer | Crochet | Rodríguez | Peña | Buxton |
| Tim Booth | The Seattle Times | SEA | Raleigh | Judge | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Rodríguez | Skubal | Springer | Peña | Crochet | Garcia |
| Ryan Divish | Seattle Times | SEA | Raleigh | Judge | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Rodríguez | Caminero | Skubal | Kurtz | Springer | Crochet |
| Martín Gallegos | MLB.com | SF | Judge | Raleigh | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Rodríguez | Skubal | Springer | Crochet | Kurtz | Buxton |
| Manolo Hernández-Douen | beisbolporgotas | SF | Raleigh | Judge | Caminero | Kurtz | Ramírez | Skubal | Witt Jr. | Guerrero Jr. | Rodríguez | Wilson |
| Adam Berry | MLB.com | TB | Judge | Raleigh | Ramírez | Witt Jr. | Rodríguez | Skubal | Springer | Crochet | Peña | Caminero |
| Marc Topkin | Tampa Bay Times | TB | Judge | Raleigh | Ramírez | Springer | Witt Jr. | Rodríguez | Crochet | Skubal | Peña | Caminero |
| Shawn McFarland | The Dallas Morning News | TEX | Judge | Raleigh | Witt Jr. | Ramírez | Skubal | Crochet | Rodríguez | Peña | Springer | Buxton |
| Kennedi Landry | MLB.com | TEX | Judge | Raleigh | Witt Jr. | Ramírez | Skubal | Rodríguez | Springer | Crochet | Peña | Buxton |
| Ben Nicholson-Smith | Sportsnet | TOR | Raleigh | Judge | Witt Jr. | Ramírez | Skubal | Rodríguez | Springer | Buxton | Peña | Crochet |
| Keegan Matheson | MLB.com | TOR | Judge | Raleigh | Witt Jr. | Ramírez | Springer | Skubal | Rodríguez | Crochet | Kurtz | Peña |