Below is a breakdown of the 30 individual ballots, submitted by two writers representing each city in the American League. For more information on the voting, see our Voting FAQ.
| Name | Affiliation | Chapter | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th | 6th | 7th | 8th | 9th | 10th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dan Connolly | The Athletic | BAL | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Ramírez | Altuve | Rodríguez | Giménez | Trout | Bichette | Rutschman |
| Zachary Silver | MLB.com | BAL | Judge | Ohtani | Giménez | Alvarez | Ramírez | Rodríguez | Altuve | Bogaerts | Trout | Rutschman |
| Ian Browne | MLB.com | BOS | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Ramírez | Trout | Altuve | Rodríguez | Verlander | Giménez | Bogaerts |
| Sean McAdam | Boston Sports Journal | BOS | Judge | Ohtani | Ramírez | Alvarez | Giménez | Trout | Rodríguez | Rutschman | Bogaerts | Altuve |
| Daryl Van Schouwen | Chicago Sun-Times | CHI | Judge | Ohtani | Ramírez | Alvarez | Giménez | Bogaerts | Bregman | Trout | Rodríguez | Rutschman |
| Jesse Rogers | ESPN | CHI | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Ramírez | Verlander | Trout | Altuve | Rodríguez | Arraez | Giménez |
| Ryan Lewis | Akron Beacon Journal | CLE | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Giménez | Rodríguez | Ramírez | Trout | Altuve | Rutschman | Bogaerts |
| Mandy Bell | MLB.com | CLE | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Giménez | Ramírez | Trout | Altuve | Rodríguez | Bogaerts | Devers |
| Jason Beck | MLB.com | DET | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Ramírez | Altuve | Giménez | Rodríguez | Trout | Bogaerts | Manoah |
| Jon Paul Morosi | MLB.com | DET | Judge | Ohtani | Ramírez | Alvarez | Rodríguez | Giménez | Bichette | Tucker | Altuve | Manoah |
| Alyson Footer | MLB.com | HOU | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Altuve | Arraez | Abreu | Giménez | Rodríguez | Guerrero Jr. | Tucker |
| Jesus Ortiz | Our Esquina | HOU | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Giménez | Altuve | Bogaerts | Ramírez | Rodríguez | Trout | Verlander |
| Anne Rogers | MLB.com | KC | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Altuve | Ramírez | Rodríguez | Verlander | Giménez | Trout | Manoah |
| Dave Skretta | The Associated Press | KC | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Bogaerts | Trout | Giménez | Rodríguez | Ramírez | Verlander | Cease |
| Greg Beacham | Associated Press | LA | Ohtani | Judge | Alvarez | Ramírez | Altuve | Giménez | Bogaerts | Verlander | Trout | Devers |
| Sam Blum | The Athletic | LA | Ohtani | Judge | Alvarez | Ramírez | Trout | Altuve | Giménez | Verlander | Rodríguez | Murphy |
| Betsy Helfand | St. Paul Pioneer Press | MIN | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Altuve | Ramírez | Verlander | Giménez | Trout | Bogaerts | Rodríguez |
| Phil Miller | Minneapolis Star Tribune | MIN | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Ramírez | Altuve | Giménez | Rodríguez | Trout | Verlander | Bogaerts |
| Marly Rivera | ESPN.COM | NY | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Ramírez | Giménez | Altuve | Devers | Rodríguez | Díaz | Trout |
| Joel Sherman | New York Post | NY | Judge | Ohtani | Ramírez | Alvarez | Rutschman | Rodríguez | Giménez | Altuve | Bogaerts | Tucker |
| Matt Kawahara | San Francisco Chronicle | OAK | Judge | Ohtani | Ramírez | Alvarez | Altuve | Rodríguez | Giménez | Trout | Bichette | Bogaerts |
| Manolo Hernández-Douen | Beisbolporgotas.com | OAK | Judge | Ohtani | Ramírez | Alvarez | Verlander | Guerrero Jr. | Arraez | Altuve | Valdez | Tucker |
| Daniel Kramer | MLB.com | SEA | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Altuve | Giménez | Ramírez | Trout | Rodríguez | Tucker | Bichette |
| Corey Brock | The Athletic | SEA | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Altuve | Giménez | Ramírez | Trout | Bogaerts | Bichette | Rodríguez |
| Marc Topkin | Tampa Bay Times | TB | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Rodríguez | Ramírez | Altuve | Bichette | Giménez | Trout | Bogaerts |
| Adam Berry | MLB.com | TB | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Ramírez | Altuve | Giménez | Rodríguez | Verlander | Manoah | Trout |
| Kennedi Landry | MLB.com | TEX | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Ramírez | Altuve | Trout | Bogaerts | Giménez | Verlander | Rodríguez |
| Levi Weaver | The Athletic | TEX | Judge | Ohtani | Giménez | Alvarez | Altuve | Rodríguez | Ramírez | Devers | Bogaerts | Verlander |
| Arden Zwelling | Sportsnet.ca | TOR | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Altuve | Trout | Ramírez | Rodríguez | Giménez | Bogaerts | Devers |
| Rob Longley | Toronto Sun | TOR | Judge | Ohtani | Alvarez | Ramírez | Rodríguez | Giménez | Trout | Verlander | Altuve | Bichette |