Below is a list of the 389 members of the BBWAA who cast ballots in the 2023 Hall of Fame election. Ballots from voters who opted to make them public will appear on this site on Feb. 7. For more on voting eligibility, see our Voting FAQ.
| Peter Abraham | Mark Feinsand | Frank Labombarda | Luis Rangel |
| Satoshi Akimura | Howard Fendrich | Santo Labombarda | Ray Ratto |
| Jim Alexander | Larry Fine | Paul Ladewski | Christian Red |
| Edward Almada | Mike Fitzpatrick | Larry Lage | Jim Reeves |
| John Altavilla | Jeffrey Flanagan | Marc Lancaster | Ben Reiter |
| David Ammenheuser | Jeff Fletcher | Scott Lauber | Troy Renck |
| Dom Amore | Sean Forman | David Laurila | Patrick Reusse |
| Anthony Andro | Barry Fritz | Keith Law | Timothy Reynolds |
| Chris Assenheimer | Tom Gage | Ryan Lawrence | Dave Reynolds |
| Andrew Baggarly | Randy Galloway | Gil LeBreton | Marla Ridenour |
| Chris Bahr | Peter Gammons | Sadiel Lebron | Anthony Rieber |
| Bill Ballou | Steve Gardner | Joe Lemire | Tracy Ringolsby |
| Daniel Barbarisi | Dan Gelston | David Lennon | Marly Rivera |
| David Barron | Dennis Georgatos | Bruce Levine | Jesse Rogers |
| Mike Bass | Rob Gillies | Brian Lewis | Phil Rogers |
| Robert Baum | Toni Ginnetti | Joseph Liao | Enrique Rojas |
| Michael Bauman | Dave Ginsburg | Seth Livingstone | Jorge Rojas |
| Greg Beacham | Brian Golden | Mike Lopresti | John Romano |
| Amalie Benjamin | Steve Goldman | Thom Loverro | C. Trent Rosecrans |
| Mike Berardino | Jimmy Golen | John Lowe | Ken Rosenthal |
| Rob Biertempfel | Mark Gonzales | Mike Lupica | Todd Rosiak |
| John Black | Derrick Goold | Rob Maaddi | Roger Rubin |
| Jeff Blair | Cormac Gordon | Brian MacPherson | Adam Rubin |
| Barry Bloom | Kevin Gorman | Bill Madden | howie rumberg |
| Ronald Blum | Rick Gosselin | John Maffei | Bob Ryan |
| Hal Bodley | Pat Graham | Dennis Maffezzoli | Bob Sansevere |
| Scott Boeck | Evan Grant | John Magruder | Eno Sarris |
| Erik Boland | Pete Grathoff | Dennis Manoloff | Patrick Saunders |
| Filip Bondy | Will Graves | Andrew Marchand | Travis Sawchik |
| Tim Booth | Teddy Greenstein | Steven Marcus | Mark Saxon |
| David Borges | Alan Greenwood | John Marshall | dick scanlon |
| Ron Borges | Scot Gregor | Tony Massarotti | Mark Schmetzer |
| Patrick Borzi | Richard Griffin | Warren Mayes | Peter Schmuck |
| Peter Botte | Paul Gutierrez | Sean McAdam | Henry Schulman |
| Rob Bradford | Joe Haakenson | Anthony McCarron | Takashi Settai |
| Mark Bradley | Chris Haft | Janie McCauley | Daniel Shaughnessy |
| Marcos Breton | Paul Hagen | Sean McClelland | John Shea |
| Larry Brooks | Mark Hale | Hal McCoy | Susan Shemanske |
| Asuka Brown | John Harper | Joe McDonald | Joel Sherman |
| Daniel Brown | Mike Harrington | Dan McGrath | Bob Sherwin |
| Steve Buckley | Beth Harris | Adam Mertz | Michael Silverman |
| Peter Caldera | Ian Harrison | Bruce Miles | Steve Simmons |
| Matthew Calkins | Tom Haudricourt | Scott Miller | Howard Sinker |
| Dave Campbell | David Haugh | Randy Miller | David Skretta |
| Nick Canepa | Marcus Hayes | Phil Miller | Susan Slusser |
| John Canzano | Daniel Hayes | Sam Miller | Joseph Smith |
| Joseph Capozzi | Jim Henneman | Larry Millson | Christopher Smith |
| Pat Caputo | Lynn Henning | Fred Mitchell | Claire Smith |
| Rene Cardenas | Marcos Hernandez | Kevin Modesti | Alexander Speier |
| Marc Carig | Manolo Hernandez-Douen | Meghan Montemurro | Clark Spencer |
| Leon Carter | Steve Herrick | Terence Moore | Jordan Sprechman |
| William Center | Mark Herrmann | Aurelio Moreno | Barry Stanton |
| Ronald Chimelis | Jon Heyman | Jon Morosi | Arnie Stapleton |
| Joe Christensen | Brian Heyman | Rick Morrissey | Shaun Powell |
| Jay Cohen | John Hickey | Pedro Moura | Jayson Stark |
| Bob Cohn | Hirozaku Higuchi | Maureen Mullen | Alex Stern |
| Lowell Cohn | Steve Hirdt | Carrie Muskat | Carl Steward |
| Gene Collier | Peter Hirdt | Gene Myers | Joe Stiglich |
| Roberto Colon | Thomas Hirdt | Katsushi Nagao | Larry Stone |
| Dan Connolly | Ken Hirdt | Marc Narducci | Gregory Strong |
| Ronald Cook | Bob Hohler | Lavelle Neal | Paul Sullivan |
| Kevin Cooney | J.P. Hoornstra | Ross Newhan | T.R. Sullivan |
| Brian Costa | Alan Hoskins | Mark Newman | Tara Sullivan |
| Greg Cote | Garry D. Howard | Bob Nightengale | Gaku Tashiro |
| Joe Cowley | Paul Hoynes | Masayoshi Niwa | Rick Telander |
| Jerry Crasnick | Rick Hummel | John Niyo | Tom Timmermann |
| Glen Crevier | Michael Hunt | Eric Nunez | John Tomase |
| Jack Curry | Bob Hunter | David O'Brien | Marc Topkin |
| Guy Curtright | Junko Ichimura | Sheldon Ocker | Robert Tracy |
| Tim Dahlberg | Mike Imrem | Jack O'Connell | Noah Trister |
| Tom D'Angelo | Jim Ingraham | Ian O'Connor | Howard Ulman |
| Dave Daniel | Jay Jaffe | Charles Odum | Mike Vaccaro |
| Kenneth Davidoff | Bruce Jenkins | Hideki Okuda | Dave Van Dyck |
| Art Davidson | Chad Jennings | Drew Olson | Daryl Van Schouwen |
| Felix DeJesus | Joey Johnston | Jesus Ortiz | Juan Vene |
| Chris DeLuca | Dick Kaegel | Jorge Ortiz | Thomas Verducci |
| Tony DeMarco | Christina Kahrl | Joe Ostermeier | Mike Waldner |
| Steve Dilbeck | Tom Keegan | Jill Painter | Charley Walters |
| Ryan Divish | Peter Kerasotis | Robert Parent | Carroll Walton |
| Schuyler Dixon | Fred Kerber | Rob Parker | Bob Waterman |
| Rustin Dodd | Kevin Kernan | Gregg Patton | Kirk Wessler |
| Josh Dubow | Ann Killion | Dave Perkins | Mark Whicker |
| Rich Dubroff | George King | John Perrotto | Paul White |
| Robert Duff | Hideo Kizaki | Mike Peticca | David Wilhelm |
| Bob Dutton | Bob Klapisch | Ed Petruska | George Willis |
| Todd Dybas | Chuck Klonke | Nick Pietruszkiewicz | Bernie Wilson |
| Charles Dybdal | Michael Knisley | Bill Plunkett | Jeff Wilson |
| Jorge Ebro | Nobuyuki Kobayashi | Terry Pluto | Bill Windler |
| Gordon Edes | Keizo Konishi | George Pohly | Steven Wine |
| bob Elliott | Stephen Kornacki | Steve Politi | Tom Withers |
| Chris Elsberry | Dejan Kovacevic | Monte Poole | Gordon Wittenmyer |
| Eduardo Encina | Ron Kroichick | Steven Popper | Bob Wojnowski |
| John Erardi | Steve Kroner | Joe Posnanski | Akiko Yamawaki |
| Jack Etkin | Roch Kubatko | Alex Pavlovic | Masashi Yamazaki |
| Bill Evans | Jeffrey Kuehn | Brendan Prunty | Mark Zuckerman |
| Ryan Fagan | Robert Kuenster | Mike Puma | |
| Mark Faller | Timothy Kurkjian | Mark Purdy | |
| John Fay | John Labombarda | Rob Rains |