Below is a list of the 385 members of the BBWAA who cast ballots in the 2024 Hall of Fame election. Ballots from voters who opted to make them public appear here. For more on voting eligibility, see our Voting FAQ.
| Peter Abraham | Ryan Fagan | Howard Kussoy | Christian Red |
| Kevin Acee | Mark Faller | John Labombarda | Joe Reedy |
| Satoshi Akimura | Mark Feinsand | Santo Labombarda | Ben Reiter |
| Jim Alexander | Howard Fendrich | Frank Labombarda | Troy Renck |
| Edward Almada | Larry Fine | Paul Ladewski | Patrick Reusse |
| John Altavilla | Mike Fitzpatrick | Larry Lage | Tim Reynolds |
| David Ammenheuser | Jefffey Flanagan | Marc Lancaster | Dave Reynolds |
| Dom Amore | Jeff Fletcher | Scott Lauber | Marla Ridenour |
| Anthony Andro | Sean Forman | David Laurila | Anthony Rieber |
| Christopher Assenheimer | Barry Fritz | Keith Law | Tracy Ringolsby |
| Andrew Baggarly | Tom Gage | Ryan Lawrence | Jesse Rogers |
| Bill Ballou | Randy Galloway | Gil LeBreton | Phil Rogers |
| Daniel Barbarisi | Peter Gammons | Sadiel Lebron | Enrique Rojas |
| David Barron | Steve Gardner | Joe Lemire | Jorge Rojas |
| Michael Bass | Joe Garza | David Lennon | John Romano |
| Robert Baum | Dan Gelston | Bruce Levine | C. Trent Rosecrans |
| Michael Bauman | Dennis Georgatos | Brian Lewis | Ken Rosenthal |
| Greg Beacham | Rob Gillies | Thom Loverro | Todd Rosiak |
| Amalie Benjamin | Toni Ginnetti | John Lowe | Roger Rubin |
| Mike Berardino | Dave Ginsburg | Michael Lupica | Adam Rubin |
| Rob Biertempfel | Jimmy Golen | Rob Maaddi | Howie Rumberg |
| John Black | Derrick Goold | Brian MacPherson | Bob Ryan |
| Jeff Blair | Cormac Gordon | Bill Madden | Jeff Sanders |
| Barry M. Bloom | Kevin Gorman | John Maffei | Bob Sansevere |
| Ronald Blum | Rick Gosselin | Dennis Maffezzoli | Eno Sarris |
| Hal Bodley | Pat Graham | Jack Magruder | Patrick Saunders |
| Scott Boeck | Evan Grant | Dennis Manoloff | Travis Sawchik |
| Erik Boland | Peter Grathoff | Andrew Marchand | Mark Saxon |
| Filip Bondy | Will Graves | Steven Marcus | Dick Scanlon |
| Tim Booth | Teddy Greenstein | John Marshall | Mark Schmetzer |
| David Borges | Alan Greenwood | Anthony Massarotti | Peter Schmuck |
| Ron Borges | Scot Gregor | Jason Mastrodonato | Henry Schulman |
| Patrick Borzi | Vahe Gregorian | Warren Mayes | Octavio Sequera |
| Peter Botte | Richard Griffin | Sean McAdam | Dan Shaughnessy |
| Dennis Brackin | Nick Groke | Anthony McCarron | John Shea |
| Rob Bradford | Joe Haakenson | Janie McCauley | Don Shelton |
| Mark Bradley | Chris Haft | Sean McClelland | Susan Shemanske |
| Zachary Braziller | Paul Hagen | Hal McCoy | Joel Sherman |
| Marcos Breton | John Harper | Joe McDonald | Bob Sherwin |
| Tim Britton | Mike Harrington | Dan McGrath | Michael Silverman |
| Larry Brooks | Beth Harris | Bruce Miles | Steve Simmons |
| Asuka Brown | Ian Harrison | Scott Miller | Howard Sinker |
| Daniel Brown | Tom Haudricourt | Randy Miller | Dave Skretta |
| David Brown | David Haugh | Phil Miller | Susan Slusser |
| Steve Buckley | Daniel Hayes | Sam Miller | Claire Smith |
| Peter Caldera | Marcus Hayes | Larry Millson | Joseph Smith |
| Dave Campbell | Jim Henneman | Kevin Modesti | Brian Smith |
| Nick Canepa | Lynn Henning | Meghan Montemurro | Christopher Smith |
| John Canzano | Manolo Hernandez-Douen | Terence Moore | Alexander Speier |
| Pat Caputo | Steve Herrick | Aurelio Moreno | Clark Spencer |
| Rene Cardenas | Mark Herrmann | Jon Morosi | Jordan Sprechman |
| Marc Carig | Jon Heyman | Rick Morrissey | Arnie Stapleton |
| Leon Carter | Brian Heyman | Maureen Mullen | Jayson Stark |
| Bill Center | John Hickey | Carrie Muskat | Alex Stern |
| Ron Chimelis | Hirokazu Higuchi | Gene Myers | Carl Steward |
| Joseph Christensen | Steve Hirdt | Katsushi Nagao | Joe Stiglich |
| Jay Cohen | Peter Hirdt | Marc Narducci | Larry Stone |
| Bob Cohn | Thomas Hirdt | Lavelle Neal | Gregory Strong |
| Gene Collier | Ken Hirdt | Paul Newberry | Paul Sullivan |
| Roberto Colon | Benjamin Hochman | Ross Newhan | TR Sullivan |
| Dan Connolly | J.P. Hoornstra | Mark Newman | Tara Sullivan |
| Ronald Cook | Alan Hoskins | Robert Nightengale | Gaku Tashiro |
| Kevin Cooney | Garry D Howard | Masayoshi Niwa | Rick Telander |
| Brian Costa | Paul Hoynes | John Niyo | Chris Thorn |
| Greg Cote | Michael Hunt | Eric Nunez | Tom Timmermann |
| Joe Cowley | Bob Hunter | David O'Brien | John Tomase |
| Jerry Crasnick | Junko Ichimura | Sheldon Ocker | Marc Topkin |
| Glen Crevier | Mike Imrem | Jack O'Connell | Robert Tracy |
| Jack Curry | Jim Ingraham | Ian O'Connor | Noah Trister |
| Guy Curtright | Jay Jaffe | Charles Odum | Howard Ulman |
| Tim Dahlberg | Bruce Jenkins | Hideki Okuda | Mike Vaccaro |
| Tom D'Angelo | Chad Jennings | Drew Olson | Daryl Van Schouwen |
| Dave Daniel | Joey Johnston | Jesus Ortiz | Juan Vene |
| Ken Davidoff | Dick Kaegel | Jorge Ortiz | Thomas Verducci |
| Art Davidson | Christina Kahrl | Joe Ostermeier | Mike Waldner |
| Felix DeJesus | Tom Keegan | Scott Ostler | Charley Walters |
| Chris DeLuca | Tyler Kepner | Jill Painter | Carroll Walton |
| Tony DeMarco | Peter Kerasotis | Robert Parent | Bob Waterman |
| Steve Dilbeck | Fred Kerber | Rob Parker | Kirk Wessler |
| Rosie DiManno | Blair Kerkhoff | Alex Pavlovic | Mark Whicker |
| Ryan Divish | Kevin Kernan | John Perrotto | Paul White |
| Schuyler Dixon | Ann Killion | Ed Petruska | David Wilhelm |
| Josh Dubow | George King | Nick Pietruszkiewicz | George Willis |
| Rich Dubroff | Hideo Kizaki | Bill Plunkett | Bernie Wilson |
| Robert Duff | Bob Klapisch | Terry Pluto | Jeff Wilson |
| Bob Dutton | Chuck Klonke | George Pohly | Bill Windler |
| Todd Dybas | Michael Knisley | Steve Politi | Steven Wine |
| Chuck Dybdal | Nobuyuki Kobayashi | Monte Poole | Hank Winnicki |
| Jorge Ebro | Keizo Konishi | Steve Popper | Tom Withers |
| Gordon Edes | Steve Kornacki | Joe Posnanski | Gordon Wittenmyer |
| Bob Elliott | Dejan Kovacevic | Shaun Powell | Bob Wojnowski |
| Chris Elsberry | Ron Kroichick | Brendan Prunty | Akiko Yamawaki |
| Eduardo Encina | Steve Kroner | Mike Puma | Masashi Yamazaki |
| Mac Engel | Roch Kubatko | Mark Purdy | Mark Zuckerman |
| John Erardi | Jeffrey Kuehn | Rob Rains | |
| Jack Etkin | Robert Kuenster | Luis Rangel | |
| Bill Evans | Tim Kurkjian | Ray Ratto |