Below is a list of the 422 members of the BBWAA who cast ballots in the 2018 Hall of Fame election. Voters who voluntarily opted to have their ballots revealed are here. For more on voting eligibility, see our Voting FAQ.
| Peter Abraham | Jorge Ebro | Ann Killion | John Perrotto |
| Dave Albee | Bob Elliott | George King | Mike Peticca |
| Jim Alexander | Chris Elsberry | Mark Kiszla | Ed Petruska |
| Edward Almada | John Erardi | Hideo Kizaki | Nick Pietruszkiewicz |
| John Altavilla | Alan Eskew | Bob Klapisch | Rick Plumlee |
| David Ammenheuser | Jack Etkin | Chuck Klonke | Bill Plunkett |
| Dom Amore | Ryan Fagan | Michael Knisley | Terry Pluto |
| Amthony Andro | Mark Faller | Danny Knobler | Steve Politi |
| Mel Antonen | Michael Fannin | Nobuyuki Kobayashi | Monte Poole |
| Jim Armstrong | John Fay | Keizo Konishi | Steve Popper |
| Kirby Arnold | Mark Feinsand | Steve Kornacki | Joe Posnanski |
| Jaime Aron | Howard Fendrich | Dejan Kovacevic | Shaun Powell |
| Chris Assenheimer | Martin Fennelly | Steven Krasner | Scott Priestle |
| Andrew Baggarly | Kenneth Fidlin | Ron Kroichick | Brendan Prunty |
| Christopher Bahr | Larry Fine | Roch Kubatko | Mike Puma |
| Bill Ballou | Mike Fitzpatrick | Jeffrey Kuehn | Mark Purdy |
| Craig Barnes | Jeffrey Flanagan | Bob Kuenster | Rob Rains |
| David Barron | Jeff Fletcher | Tim Kurkjian | Luis Rangel |
| Peter Barzilai | Carlos Frias | John Labombarda | Ray Ratto |
| Mike Bass | Barry Fritz | Santo Labombarda | Jim Reeves |
| Robert Baum | Carter Gaddis | Gabe Lacques | Troy Renck |
| Michael Bauman | Tom Gage | Paul Ladewski | Patrick Reusse |
| Greg Beacham | Greg Gallo | Keith Lair | David Reynolds |
| Darrin Beene | Randy Galloway | Marc Lancaster | Tim Reynolds |
| Amalie Benjamin | Peter Gammons | Bill Lankhof | Anthony Rieber |
| Mike Berardino | James Gauger | Scott Lauber | Tracy Ringolsby |
| Rob Biertempfel | Dan Gelston | Ryan Lawrence | Alan Robinson |
| John Black | Dennis Georgatos | Sadiel Lebron | Phil Rogers |
| William Jeffrey Blair | Joseph Gergen | David Lennon | Jorge Rojas |
| Fran Blinebury | Greg Gibson | Joseph Liao | John Romano |
| Barry Bloom | Steven Gietschier | Bernard Lincicome | C. Trent Rosecrans |
| Earl Bloom | Rob Gillies | Bill Livingston | Ken Rosenthal |
| Ronald Blum | Toni Ginnetti | Seth Livingstone | John Rowe |
| Paul Bodi | Dave Ginsburg | John Lopez | Barry Rozner |
| Hal Bodley | Steve Goldman | Mike Lopresti | Roger Rubin |
| Erik Boland | Jimmy Golen | Thom Loverro | Richard Rupprecht |
| Filip Bondy | Pedro Gomez | John Lowe | Joe Rutter |
| Tim Booth | Mark Gonzales | Mike Lupica | Bob Ryan |
| David Borges | Derrick Goold | Rob Maaddi | Bob Sansevere |
| Patrick Borzi | Cormac Gordon | Bill Madden | Naoko Sato |
| Don Bostrom | Rick Gosselin | John Maffei | Toshinori Sawada |
| Peter Botte | Pat Graham | Dennis Maffezzoli | Mark Saxon |
| Dennis Brackin | Evan Grant | Jack Magruder | Dick Scanlon |
| Mark Bradley | Dan Graziano | Dennis Manoloff | Mark Schmetzer |
| Marcos Breton | Jerry Green | Steven Marcus | Henry Schulman |
| Larry Brooks | Jay Greenberg | David Maril | Glenn Schwarz |
| Garry Brown | Alan Greenwood | Marino Martinez | Charles Scoggins Jr |
| Ray Buck | Scot Gregor | Tony Massarotti | Takashi Settai |
| Steve Buckley | Richard Griffin | Warren Mayes | Mike Shalin |
| Don Burke | Karen Guregian | Sean McAdam | Dan Shaughnessy |
| Dave Buscema | Paul Gutierrez | Jack McCaffery | John Shea |
| Nick Cafardo | Joe Haakenson | Anthony McCarron | Susan Shemanske |
| Peter Caldera | Chris Haft | Janie McCauley | Joel Sherman |
| Andrew Call | Paul Hagen | Sean McClelland | Bob Sherwin |
| Dave Campbell | Mark Hale | Hal McCoy | Richard Shook |
| Nick Canepa | John Harper | Joe McDonald | Michael Silverman |
| John Canzano | Mike Harrington | Dan McGrath | Steve Simmons |
| Jim Caple | Beth Harris | John McGrath | Seymour Siwoff |
| Joe Capozzi | Ian Harrison | Lenny Megliola | Susan Slusser |
| Pat Caputo | Sidney Hartman | Samuel Mellinger | Willie Smith |
| Sam Carchidi | Bill Hartman | Adam Mertz | Claire Smith |
| Rene Cardenas | Tom Haudricourt | Paul Meyer | Joe Smith |
| Marc Carig | Jim Hawkins | Bruce Miles | Bob Smizik |
| Les Carpenter | Dan Hayes | Scott Miller | Clark Spencer |
| John Carson | Joe Henderson | Jeff Miller | Barry Stanton |
| Bill Center | Cathy Henkel | Randy Miller | Arnie Stapleton |
| Murray Chass | Jim Henneman | Phil Miller | Jayson Stark |
| Ron Chimelis | Lynn Henning | Larry Millson | Alex Stern |
| Joe Christensen | Steve Henson | Steve Milton | Carl Steward |
| Tom Christensen | Manolo Hernandez-Douen | Fred Mitchell | Joe Stiglich |
| Jay Cohen | Steve Herrick | Kevin Modesti | Larry Stone |
| Bob Cohn | Mark Herrmann | Roger Mooney | Jim Street |
| Lowell Cohn | Robert Herzog | Terence Moore | Paul Sullivan |
| Gene Collier | Roy Hewitt | Aurelio Moreno | TR Sullivan |
| Roberto Colon | Jon Heyman | Jon Morosi | Gaku Tashiro |
| Dan Connolly | Brian Heyman | Rick Morrissey | Jean-Jacques Taylor |
| Ron Cook | John Hickey | Irvin Moss | Rick Telander |
| Kevin Cooney | Hirokazu Higuchi | Chuck Murr | Chris Thorn |
| Brian Costello | Steve Hirdt | Carrie Muskat | Tom Timmermann |
| Greg Cote | Peter Hirdt | Gene Myers | John Tomase |
| Joe Cowley | Thomas Hirdt | John Nadel | Marc Topkin |
| Tim Cowlishaw | Ken Hirdt | Mike Nadel | Douglas Tucker |
| Jerry Crasnick | Bob Hohler | Katsushi Nagao | Howard Ulman |
| Glen Crevier | Jeff Horrigan | Lavelle Neal | Mike Vaccaro |
| Jack Curry | Alan Hoskins | Paul Newberry | Dave Van Dyck |
| Guy Curtright | Garry D. Howard | Ross Newhan | Juan Vene |
| Tom D'Angelo | Paul Hoynes | Mark Newman | Tom Verducci |
| Tim Dahlberg | Dave Hughes | Robert Nightengale | Constantino Viloria |
| Dave Daniel | Rick Hummel | Marty Noble | Mike Waldner |
| Paul Daugherty | Michael Hunt | Eric Nunez | Charley Walters |
| Shi Davidi | Bob Hunter | Jack O'Connell | Carroll Walton |
| Ken Davidoff | Gary Hyvonen | Ian O'Connor | Bob Waterman |
| Art Davidson | Junko Ichimura | Sheldon Ocker | Kirk Wessler |
| John Delcos | Mike Imrem | Charles Odum | Mark Whicker |
| Chris DeLuca | Jim Ingraham | Hideki Okuda | Paul White |
| Tony DeMarco | Jeff Jacobs | Drew Olson | David Wilhelm |
| Tom Dienhart | Bruce Jenkins | Jorge Ortiz | George Willis |
| Steve Dilbeck | Chuck Johnson | Jose de Jesus Ortiz | Bernie Wilson |
| Ryan Divish | Joey Johnston | Joe Ostermeier | Jeff Wilson |
| Mike Dodd | Richard Justice | Lawrence Pantages | Bill Windler |
| Mike Downey | Dick Kaegel | Rob Parker | Steven Wine |
| Josh Dubow | Marc Katz | Peter Pascarelli | Gordon Wittenmyer |
| Bob Duff | Tim Kawakami | Gregg Patton | Bob Wojnowski |
| Jay Dunn | Joe Kay | Jeff Peek | Akiko Yamawaki |
| Bob Dutton | Tom Keegan | Dave Perkins | Mark Zuckerman |
| Chuck Dybdal | Kevin Kernan |