Below is a breakdown of the 30 individual ballots, submitted by two writers representing each city in the American League. Note that in some cases (*), if a city does not have enough eligible voters, a voter from another city will represent that chapter. For more information on the voting, see our Voting FAQ.
| Name | Affiliation | Chapt. | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th | 6th | 7th | 8th | 9th | 10th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ken Rosenthal | Fox Sports | BAL | Trout | Donaldson | Cain | Machado | Keuchel | Price | Beltre | Bautista | Cruz | C.Davis |
| Rich Dubroff | CSNmidatlantic.com | BAL | Donaldson | Trout | Cain | Machado | Bautista | Encarnacion | Cruz | Cabrera | C.Davis | Altuve |
| Michael Silverman | Boston Herald | BOS | Donaldson | Trout | Cain | Machado | Keuchel | Price | Beltre | C.Davis | Martinez | Cruz |
| Peter Abraham | Boston Globe | BOS | Donaldson | Trout | Cain | Machado | Keuchel | Price | Beltre | Kinsler | Kiermaier | Betts |
| Scot Gregor | Daily Herald | CHI | Donaldson | Trout | Cain | Beltre | Encarnacion | Altuve | Cabrera | Machado | Bautista | Hosmer |
| Naoko Sato | Nikkan Sports News | CHI | Donaldson | Trout | Cain | Keuchel | Fielder | Cruz | Bautista | Price | Machado | Ortiz |
| Chris Assenheimer | The Chronicle-Telegram | CLE | Donaldson | Cruz | Trout | Cain | Fielder | Altuve | Encarnacion | Abreu | Martinez | Brantley |
| Paul Hoynes | NE Ohio Media Group | CLE | Donaldson | Trout | Bautista | Cain | Fielder | Encarnacion | Davis | Cruz | Machado | Martinez |
| Anthony Fenech | Detroit Free Press | DET | Donaldson | Trout | Cain | Price | Machado | Keuchel | Martinez | Beltre | Cruz | Martin |
| Chris McCosky | Detroit News | DET | Donaldson | Trout | Cain | Cruz | Machado | Keuchel | Bautista | Encarnacion | Beltre | Martinez |
| Evan Drellich | Houston Chronicle | HOU | Donaldson | Trout | Machado | Keuchel | Price | Cain | Cruz | C.Davis | Bautista | Beltre |
| Jesus Ortiz | Houston Chronicle | HOU | Donaldson | Trout | Machado | Cain | Cabrera | Bautista | Beltre | Keuchel | Cruz | Price |
| Joe Posnanski | NBCSports.com | KC | Trout | Donaldson | Cain | Machado | Keuchel | Cruz | C.Davis | Cabrera | Fielder | W.Davis |
| Sam Mellinger | Kansas City Star | KC | Trout | Donaldson | Cain | Machado | Kipnis | Martinez | C.Davis | Betts | Kiermaier | Beltre |
| Tim Brown | Yahoo Sports | LA | Trout | Donaldson | Machado | Cain | Cruz | Bautista | C.Davis | Keuchel | Cabrera | Beltre |
| Pedro Moura | Orange County Register | LA | Trout | Donaldson | Machado | Cain | Price | Keuchel | Sale | Kipnis | Beltre | Martin |
| La Velle E. Neal III | Minneapolis Star Tribune | MIN | Donaldson | Trout | Cain | Kipnis | Machado | Fielder | Cabrera | Altuve | Cruz | Martinez |
| Mike Berardino | St. Paul Pioneer Press | MIN | Donaldson | Trout | Cain | Machado | Keuchel | Encarnacion | Beltre | Price | Cruz | Hosmer |
| Wallace Matthews | ESPN.com | NY | Donaldson | Trout | Price | Cain | Keuchel | Machado | Beltre | Altuve | C.Davis | Kiermaier |
| George A. King III | NY Post | NY | Donaldson | Trout | Bautista | Morales | Fielder | Altuve | Cain | Encarnacion | McCann | Cruz |
| Susan Slusser | San Francisco Chronicle | OAK | Donaldson | Trout | Cain | Beltre | Keuchel | Kiermaier | Machado | Altuve | Bautista | C.Davis |
| John Hickey | Oakland Tribune | OAK | Donaldson | Trout | Cain | Beltre | Bautista | Altuve | Keuchel | Cruz | Price | Machado |
| Ryan Divish | Seattle Times | SEA | Donaldson | Trout | Cain | Machado | Cruz | Cabrera | Beltre | Keuchel | Bautista | Price |
| John McGrath | Tacoma News Tribune | SEA | Donaldson | Trout | Cabrera | Cain | Cruz | Bautista | Altuve | Encarnacion | Machado | Dozier |
| Marc Topkin | Tampa Bay Times | TB | Donaldson | Trout | Cain | Beltre | Machado | Keuchel | Price | Bautista | Cruz | Rodriguez |
| Roger Mooney | Tampa Tribune | TB | Donaldson | Trout | Cain | Machado | Price | Keuchel | Cruz | Bautista | Cabrera | Fielder |
| Gerry Fraley | Dallas Morning News | TEX | Trout | Donaldson | Cain | Keuchel | Beltre | Altuve | Encarnacion | Moustakas | Bautista | Fielder |
| Jeff Wilson | Fort Worth Star-Telegram | TEX | Trout | Donaldson | Cruz | Cain | Machado | Bautista | C.Davis | Beltre | Correa | Cabrera |
| Richard Griffin | Toronto Star | TOR | Donaldson | Trout | Cain | Machado | Cruz | Altuve | Bautista | Beltre | Martinez | Kipnis |
| Bob Elliott | Toronto Sun | TOR | Donaldson | Trout | Cain | Machado | Keuchel | Beltre | Cruz | Bautista | Cabrera | Teixeira |