Below is a list of the 442 members of the BBWAA who cast ballots in the 2017 Hall of Fame election. Voters who voluntarily revealed their ballots are shown here. For more on voting eligibility, see our Voting FAQ.
| Peter Abraham | Alan Eskew | Nobuyuki Kobayashi | Bill Plunkett |
| Bill Abramson | Jack Etkin | Keizo Konishi | Terry Pluto |
| Dave Albee | Ryan Fagan | Steve Kornacki | George Pohly |
| Jim Alexander | Mark Faller | Dejan Kovacevic | Steve Politi |
| Edward Almada | R.B. Fallstrom | Steven Krasner | Monte Poole |
| John Altavilla | Mike Fannin | Mark Kreidler | Steve Popper |
| David Ammenheuser | John Fay | Dave Krieger | Joe Posnanski |
| Dom Amore | Mark Feinsand | Ron Kroichick | Shaun Powell |
| Mel Antonen | Howard Fendrich | Roch Kubatko | Thomas Powers |
| Jim Armstrong | Martin Fennelly | Jeff Kuehn | Scott Priestle |
| Kirby Arnold | Ken Fidlin | Robert Kuenster | Mike Puma |
| Jaime Aron | Mike Fitzpatrick | Tim Kurkjian | Mark Purdy |
| Chris Assenheimer | Jeffrey Flanagan | John Labombarda | Rob Rains |
| Paul Attner | Jeff Fletcher | Santo Labombarda | Ron Rapoport |
| Andrew Baggarly | Carlos Frias | Gabe Lacques | Ray Ratto |
| Chris Bahr | Barry Fritz | Paul Ladewski | Christian Red |
| Bill Ballou | Carter Gaddis | Larry Lage | Jim Reeves |
| Craig Barnes | Tom Gage | Keith Lair | Troy Renck |
| David Barron | Gregory Gallo | Marc Lancaster | Patrick Reusse |
| Peter Barzilai | Randy Galloway | Bill Lankhof | David Reynolds |
| Mike Bass | Peter Gammons | David Lariviere | Tim Reynolds |
| Bob Baum | Jim Gauger | Scott Lauber | Anthony Rieber |
| Michael Bauman | Dan Gelston | Gil LeBreton | Tracy Ringolsby |
| Greg Beacham | Denny Georgatos | Mike Lefkow | Brendan Roberts |
| Darrin Beene | Joe Gergen | David Lennon | Alan Robinson |
| Amalie Benjamin | Greg Gibson | Joseph Liao | Phil Rogers |
| Mike Berardino | Steven Gietschier | Bernard Lincicome | Jorge Rojas |
| Rob Biertempfel | Rob Gillies | William Livingston | John Romano |
| John Black | Toni Ginnetti | Seth Livingstone | C Trent Rosecrans |
| Jeff Blair | Dave Ginsburg | John Lopez | Robert Rosen |
| Fran Blinebury | Brian Golden | Mike Lopresti | Ken Rosenthal |
| Barry Bloom | Jimmy Golen | Thomas Loverro | John Rowe |
| Earl Bloom | Pedro Gomez | John Lowe | Barry Rozner |
| Ronald Blum | Mark Gonzales | Ruben Luna | Adam Rubin |
| Paul Bodi | Derrick Goold | Mike Lupica | Roger Rubin |
| Hal Bodley | Cormac Gordon | Rob Maaddi | Richard Rupprecht |
| Filip Bondy | Rick Gosselin | Bill Madden | Joe Rutter |
| Tim Booth | Pat Graham | John Maffei | Bob Ryan |
| Scott Bordow | Evan Grant | Dennis Maffezzoli | Bob Sansevere |
| David Borges | Dan Graziano | Jack Magruder | Toshinori Sawada |
| Patrick Borzi | Jerry Green | Dennis Manoloff | Mark Saxon |
| Don Bostrom | Jay Greenberg | Steven Marcus | Dick Scanlon |
| Peter Botte | Alan Greenwood | David Maril | Mark Schmetzer |
| Dennis Brackin | Scot Gregor | Art Martone | Henry Schulman |
| Mark Bradley | Richard Griffin | Anthony Massarotti | Jeff Schultz |
| Stephen Bray | Karen Guregian | Warren Mayes | Glenn Schwarz |
| Marcos Breton | Paul Gutierrez | Sean McAdam | Charles Scoggins |
| Larry Brooks | Joe Haakenson | Jack McCaffery | Takashi Settai |
| Garry Brown | Chris Haft | Anthony McCarron | Mike Shalin |
| Ray Buck | Paul Hagen | Janie McCauley | Dan Shaughnessy |
| Steve Buckley | Mark Hale | Sean McClelland | John Shea |
| Don Burke | John Harper | Hal McCoy | Susan Shemanske |
| Dave Buscema | Mike Harrington | Joe McDonald | Joel Sherman |
| Nicholas Cafardo | Beth Harris | John McGrath | Bob Sherwin |
| Peter Caldera | Ian Harrison | Dan McGrath | Richard Shook |
| Andrew Call | Bill Hartman | Sam Mellinger | Mike Silverman |
| Dave Campbell | Tom Haudricourt | Adam Mertz | Steve Simmons |
| Nick Canepa | Jim Hawkins | Paul Meyer | Seymour Siwoff |
| John Canzano | Dan Hayes | Bruce Miles | Susan Slusser |
| Jim Caple | Joe Henderson | Randy Miller | Claire Smith |
| Joe Capozzi | Cathy Henkel | Scott Miller | Willie Smith |
| Pat Caputo | Jim Henneman | Jeff Miller | Bob Smizik |
| Rene Cardenas | Lynn Henning | Phil Miller | Lyle Spencer |
| Les Carpenter | Steve Henson | Larry Millson | Clark Spencer |
| John Carson | Manolo Hernandez-Douen | Steve Milton | Barry Stanton |
| Bill Center | Steve Herrick | Fred Mitchell | Arnie Stapleton |
| Murray Chass | Mark Herrmann | Kevin Modesti | Jayson Stark |
| Ron Chimelis | Bob Hertzel | Jim Molony | Alex Stern |
| Tom Christensen | Bob Herzog | Roger Mooney | Carl Steward |
| Joe Christensen | Roy Hewitt | Terence Moore | Joe Stiglich |
| Lowell Cohn | Jon Heyman | Aurelio Moreno | Larry Stone |
| Bob Cohn | Brian Heyman | Jon Morosi | Jim Street |
| Gene Collier | John Hickey | Rick Morrissey | TR Sullivan |
| Roberto Colon | Hirokazu Higuchi | Irv Moss | Paul Sullivan |
| Dan Connolly | Ed Hilt | Chuck Murr | Gaku Tashiro |
| Ron Cook | Peter Hirdt | Carrie Muskat | Jean-Jacques Taylor |
| Kevin Cooney | Thomas Hirdt | Gene Myers | Rick Telander |
| Brian Costello | Kenneth Hirdt | John Nadel | Chris Thorn |
| Greg Cote | Steve Hirdt | Mike Nadel | Tom Timmermann |
| Joe Cowley | Bob Hohler | Lavelle Neal III | John Tomase |
| Tim Cowlishaw | Joseph Hoppel | Paul Newberry | Marc Topkin |
| Jerry Crasnick | Jeff Horrigan | Mark Newman | Douglas Tucker |
| Glen Crevier | Alan Hoskins | Robert Nightengale | Howard Ulman |
| Jack Curry | Garry Howard | Marty Noble | Mike Vaccaro |
| Guy Curtright | Paul Hoynes | Eric Nunez | Dave Van Dyck |
| Tim Dahlberg | David Hughes | Sheldon Ocker | Juan Vene |
| Tom D'Angelo | Rick Hummel | Jack O'Connell | Rick Ventura |
| Dave Daniel | Michael Hunt | Ian O'Connor | Tom Verducci |
| Paul Daugherty | Bob Hunter | Charles Odum | Constantino Viloria |
| Shi Davidi | Barney Hutchinson | Hideki Okuda | Jeff Vorva |
| Kenneth Davidoff | Gary Hyvonen | Drew Olson | Mike Waldner |
| Art Davidson | Mike Imrem | Shaun O'Neill | Charley Walters |
| John Delcos | Jim Ingraham | Jose de Jesus Ortiz | Carroll Walton |
| Chris DeLuca | Jeff Jacobs | Jorge Ortiz | Bob Waterman |
| Tony DeMarco | Bruce Jenkins | Joe Ostermeier | Kirk Wessler |
| Tom Dienhart | Chuck Johnson | Bob Padecky | Mark Whicker |
| Steve Dilbeck | Joey Johnston | Doug Padilla | Paul White |
| Vincent DiTrani | Richard Justice | Jill Painter-Lopez | David Wilhelm |
| Mike Dodd | Dick Kaegel | Lawrence Pantages | Jack E. Wilkinson |
| Bob Dolgan | Marc Katz | Jay Paris | George Willis |
| Mike Downey | Tim Kawakami | Rob Parker | Bernie Wilson |
| Paul Doyle | Joe Kay | Peter Pascarelli | Bill Windler |
| Josh Dubow | Tom Keegan | Jeffrey Passan | Steven Wine |
| Jay Dunn | Peter Kerasotis | Gregg Patton | Gordon Wittenmyer |
| Bob Dutton | Kevin Kernan | Jeff Peek | Bob Wojnowski |
| Chuck Dybdal | Ann Killion | Dave Perkins | Gregg Wong |
| Jorge Ebro | George King | John Perrotto | Akiko Yamawaki |
| John Eisenberg | Bob Klapish | Mike Peticca | Tom Yantz |
| Bob Elliott | Chuck Klonke | Ed Petruska | Mark Zuckerman |
| Chris Ellsberry | Mike Knisley | Nick Pietruszkiewicz | |
| John Erardi | Danny Knobler | Rick Plumlee |