Below is a list of the 425 members of the BBWAA who cast ballots in the 2019 Hall of Fame election. Ballots from voters who opted to make them public will appear on this site at a later date. For more on voting eligibility, see our Voting FAQ.
| Peter Abraham | Bob Elliott | Hideo Kizaki | Terry Pluto |
| Dave Albee | Chris Elsberry | Bob Klapisch | George Pohly |
| Jim Alexander | John Erardi | Chuck Klonke | Steve Politi |
| Edward Almada | Alan Eskew | Michael Knisley | Monte Poole |
| John Altavilla | Jack Etkin | Danny Knobler | Steven Popper |
| David Ammenheuser | Ryan Fagan | Nobuyuki Kobayashi | Joe Posnanski |
| Dom Amore | Mark Faller | Keizo Konishi | Shaun Powell |
| Anthony Andro | John Fay | Steve Kornacki | Scott Priestle |
| Mel Antonen | Mark Feinsand | Dejan Kovacevic | Brendan Prunty |
| Jim Armstrong | Howard Fendrich | Steven Krasner | Mike Puma |
| Kirby Arnold | Martin Fennelly | Ron Kroichick | Mark Purdy |
| Jaime Aron | Ken Fidlin | Roch Kubatko | Rob Rains |
| Chris Assenheimer | Larry Fine | Jeffrey Kuehn | Luis Rangel |
| Andrew Baggarly | Mike Fitzpatrick | Robert Kuenster | Ray Ratto |
| Chris Bahr | Jeffrey Flanagan | Tim Kurkjian | Christian Red |
| Bill Ballou | Jeff Fletcher | John Labombarda | Jim Reeves |
| Daniel Barbarisi | Gerry Fraley | Santo Labombarda | Troy Renck |
| Craig Barnes | Carlos Frias | Gabe Lacques | Patrick Reusse |
| David Barron | Barry Fritz | Paul Ladewski | David Reynolds |
| Peter Barzilai | Carter Gaddis | Larry Lage | Timothy Reynolds |
| Mike Bass | Tom Gage | Keith Lair | Anthony Rieber |
| Bob Baum | Greg Gallo | Marc Lancaster | Tracy Ringolsby |
| Michael Bauman | Randy Galloway | Bill Lankhof | Alan Robinson |
| Greg Beacham | Peter Gammons | Scott Lauber | Phil Rogers |
| Darrin Beene | James Gauger | Keith Law | Enrique Rojas |
| Amalie Benjamin | Dan Gelston | Ryan Lawrence | Jorge Rojas |
| Mike Berardino | Dennis Georgatos | Gil LeBreton | John Romano |
| Rob Biertempfel | Bud Geracie | Sadiel Lebron | C. Trent Rosecrans |
| John Black | Rob Gillies | David Lennon | Ken Rosenthal |
| Jeff Blair | Toni Ginnetti | Joseph Liao | John Rowe |
| Fran Blinebury | Dave Ginsburg | Bernie Lincicome | Barry Rozner |
| Barry Bloom | Bran Golden | Seth Livingstone | Adam Rubin |
| Earl Bloom | Steven Goldman | Jill Lopez | Roger Rubin |
| Ronald Blum | Jimmy Golen | John Lopez | Richard Rupprecht |
| Paul Bodi | Pedro Gomez | Mike Lopresti | Joe Rutter |
| Hal Bodley | Mark Gonzales | Thom Loverro | Bob Ryan |
| Erik Boland | Derrick Goold | John Lowe | Bob Sansevere |
| Filip Bondy | Cormac Gordon | Mike Lupica | Naoko Sato |
| Tim Booth | Rick Gosselin | Rob Maaddi | Toshinori Sawada |
| Scott Bordow | Pat Graham | Bill Madden | Mark Saxon |
| Ron Borges | Evan Grant | John Maffei | Dick Scanlon |
| David Borges | Dan Graziano | Dennis Maffezzoli | Mark Schmetzer |
| Patrick Borzi | Jerry Green | Jack Magruder | Henry Schulman |
| Peter Botte | Jay Greenberg | Dennis Manoloff | Glenn Schwarz |
| Dennis Brackin | Teddy Greenstein | Steven Marcus | Charles Scoggins |
| Mark Bradley | Alan Greenwood | David Maril | Mike Shalin |
| Marcos Breton | Scot Gregor | Marino Martinez | Dan Shaughnessy |
| Larry Brooks | Richard Griffin | Tony Massarotti | John Shea |
| Garry Brown | Karen Guregian | Warren Mayes | Susan Shemanske |
| Howard Bryant | Paul Gutierrez | Sean McAdam | Joel Sherman |
| Ray Buck | Joe Haakenson | Jack McCaffery | Bob Sherwin |
| Steve Buckley | Chris Haft | Anthony McCarron | Richard Shook |
| Don Burke | Paul Hagen | Janie McCauley | Michael Silverman |
| Nick Cafardo | Mark Hale | Sean McClelland | Steve Simmons |
| Peter Caldera | John Harper | Hal McCoy | Howard Sinker |
| Dave Campbell | Mike Harrington | Joe McDonald | Seymour Siwoff |
| Nick Canepa | Beth Harris | Dan McGrath | Susan Slusser |
| John Canzano | Ian Harrison | John McGrath | Joseph Smith |
| Jim Caple | Sidney Hartman | Lenny Megliola | Willie Smith |
| Joe Capozzi | Bill Hartman | Sam Mellinger | Claire Smith |
| Pat Caputo | Thomas Haudricourt | Adam Mertz | Clark Spencer |
| Rene Cardenas | Jim Hawkins | Bruce Miles | Arnie Stapleton |
| Marc Carig | Dan Hayes | Scott Miller | Jayson Stark |
| John Carson | Joe Henderson | Randy Miller | Alex Stern |
| Leon Carter | Jim Henneman | Phil Miller | Carl Steward |
| Bill Center | Lynn Henning | Larry Millson | Joe Stiglich |
| Murray Chass | Steve Henson | Fred Mitchell | Larry Stone |
| Ronald Chimelis | Manolo Hernandez-Douen | Kevin Modesti | Jim Street |
| Joe Christensen | Steve Herrick | Terence Moore | Paul Sullivan |
| Tom Christensen | Mark Herrmann | Aurelio Moreno | T.R. Sullivan |
| Jay Cohen | Bob Herzog | Jon Morosi | Gaku Tashiro |
| Lowell Cohn | Roy Hewitt | Rick Morrissey | Jean-Jacques Taylor |
| Bob Cohn | Jon Heyman | Irvin Moss | Rick Telander |
| Gene Collier | Brian Heyman | Chuck Murr | Chris Thorn |
| Roberto Colon | John Hickey | Carrie Muskat | Tom Timmermann |
| Dan Connolly | Hirokazu Higuchi | Gene Myers | John Tomase |
| Ron Cook | Steve Hirdt | Mike Nadel | Marc Topkin |
| Kevin Cooney | Peter Hirdt | John Nadel | Douglas Tucker |
| Brian Costa | Ken Hirdt | Katsushi Nagao | Howard Ulman |
| Brian Costello | Thomas Hirdt | Lavelle Neal | Mike Vaccaro |
| Greg Cote | Bob Hohler | Paul Newberry | Dave Van Dyck |
| Joe Cowley | Jeff Horrigan | Ross Newhan | Juan Vene |
| Tim Cowlishaw | Alan Hoskins | Mark Newman | Tom Verducci |
| Jerry Crasnick | Garry Howard | Robert Nightengale | Constantino Viloria |
| Glen Crevier | Paul Hoynes | Marty Noble | Mike Waldner |
| Jack Curry | Rick Hummel | Eric Nunez | Charley Walters |
| Guy Curtright | Michael Hunt | David O'Brien | Carroll Walton |
| Tim Dahlberg | Bob Hunter | Sheldon Ocker | Bob Waterman |
| Tom D'Angelo | Junko Ichimura | Jack O'Connell | Kirk Wessler |
| Dave Daniel | Mike Imrem | Ian O'Connor | Mark Whicker |
| Paul Daugherty | Jim Ingraham | Charles Odum | Paul White |
| Shi Davidi | Jeff Jacobs | Hideki Okuda | David Wilhelm |
| Ken Davidoff | Bruce Jenkins | Andrew Olson | George Willis |
| Art Davidson | Joey Johnston | Jesus Ortiz | Bernie Wilson |
| Felix DeJesus | Richard Justice | Jorge Ortiz | Jeff Wilson |
| John Delcos | Dick Kaegel | Joseph Ostermeier | Bill Windler |
| Chris DeLuca | Christina Kahrl | Larry Pantages | Steven Wine |
| Tony DeMarco | Marc Katz | Robert Parent | Hank Winnicki |
| Steve Dilbeck | Tim Kawakami | Rob Parker | Tom Withers |
| Ryan Divish | Joe Kay | Peter Pascarelli | Gordon Wittenmyer |
| Mike Dodd | Tom Keegan | Gregg Patton | Bob Wojnowski |
| Josh Dubow | Peter Kerasotis | Dave Perkins | Gregg Wong |
| Bob Duff | Fred Kerber | John Perrotto | Akiko Yamawaki |
| Jay Dunn | Kevin Kernan | Mike Peticca | Mark Zuckerman |
| Bob Dutton | Ann Killion | Ed Petruska | |
| Chuck Dybdal | George King | Nick Pietruszkiewicz | |
| Jorge Ebro | Mark Kiszla | Bill Plunkett |