Below is a list of the 401 members of the BBWAA who cast ballots in the 2021 Hall of Fame election. Ballots from voters who opted to make them public will appear on this site at a later date. For more on voting eligibility, see our Voting FAQ.
| Peter Abraham | Mark Faller | Steven Krasner | Shaun Powell |
| Satoshi Akimura | John Fay | Ron Kroichick | Brendan Prunty |
| Jim Alexander | Mark Feinsand | Roch Kubatko | Mike Puma |
| Edward Almada | Howard Fendrich | Jeff Kuehn | Mark Purdy |
| John Altavilla | Ken Fidlin | Robert Kuenster | Rob Rains |
| David Ammenheuser | Larry Fine | Tim Kurkjian | Luis Rangel |
| Dom Amore | Mike Fitzpatrick | John Labombarda | Ray Ratto |
| Anthony Andro | Jeffrey Flanagan | Santo Labombarda | Christian Red |
| Mel Antonen | Jeff Fletcher | Gabe Lacques | Jim Reeves |
| Jim Armstrong | Sean Forman | Paul Ladewski | Ben Reiter |
| Kirby Arnold | Barry Fritz | Larry Lage | Troy Renck |
| Jaime Aron | Tom Gage | Marc Lancaster | Patrick Reusse |
| Chris Assenheimer | Randy Galloway | Bill Lankhof | David Reynolds |
| David Avila | Peter Gammons | Scott Lauber | Timothy Reynolds |
| Andrew Baggarly | Stephen Gardner | David Laurila | Marla Ridenour |
| Chris Bahr | Matt Gelb | Keith Law | Anthony Rieber |
| Bill Ballou | Dan Gelston | Ryan Lawrence | Tracy Ringolsby |
| Daniel Barbarisi | Dennis Georgatos | Gil LeBreton | Alan Robinson |
| David Barron | Rob Gillies | Sadiel Lebron | Phil Rogers |
| Peter Barzilai | Toni Ginnetti | Joe Lemire | Enrique Rojas |
| Mike Bass | David Ginsburg | David Lennon | Jorge Rojas |
| Robert Baum | Brian Golden | Brian Lewis | John Romano |
| Michael Bauman | Steve Goldman | Joseph Liao | C. Trent Rosecrans |
| Greg Beacham | Jimmy Golen | Seth Livingstone | Ken Rosenthal |
| Amalie Benjamin | Pedro Gomez | Mike Lopresti | Todd Rosiak |
| Michael Berardino | Mark Gonzales | Thom Loverro | Barry Rozner |
| Rob Biertempfel | Derrick Goold | John Lowe | Roger Rubin |
| John Black | Cormac Gordon | Mike Lupica | Adam Rubin |
| William Blair | Kevin Gorman | Rob Maaddi | Howie Rumberg |
| Barry Bloom | Rick Gosselin | Brian MacPherson | Bob Ryan |
| Earl Bloom | Pat Graham | Bill Madden | Bob Sansevere |
| Ronald Blum | Evan Grant | John Maffei | Al Saracevic |
| Paul Bodi | Dan Graziano | Dennis Maffezzoli | Toshinori Sawada |
| Hal Bodley | Teddy Greenstein | Jack Magruder | Mark Saxon |
| Erik Boland | Alan Greenwood | Dennis Manoloff | Dick Scanlon |
| Filip Bondy | Scot Gregor | Andrew Marchand | Mark Schmetzer |
| Tim Booth | Richard Griffin | Steven Marcus | Henry Schulman |
| David Borges | Karen Guregian | David Maril | Charles Scoggins |
| Patrick Borzi | Paul Gutierrez | John Marshall | Dan Shaughnessy |
| Peter Botte | Joe Haakenson | Marino Martinez | John Shea |
| Mark Bradley | Christopher Haft | Tony Massarotti | Don Shelton |
| Marcos Breton | Paul Hagen | Warren Mayes | Susan Shemanske |
| Larry Brooks | Mark Hale | Sean McAdam | Joel Sherman |
| Asuka Brown | John Harper | Jack McCaffery | Bob Sherwin |
| Ray Buck | Mike Harrington | Anthony McCarron | Richard Shook |
| Steve Buckley | Beth Harris | Janie McCauley | Michael Silverman |
| Peter Caldera | Ian Harrison | Sean McClelland | Steve Simmons |
| Dave Campbell | Bill Hartman | Hal McCoy | Howard Sinker |
| Nick Canepa | Tom Haudricourt | Joe McDonald | David Skretta |
| John Canzano | David Haugh | Dan McGrath | Susan Slusser |
| JIm Caple | Jim Hawkins | Sam Mellinger | Joseph Smith |
| Joe Capozzi | Dan Hayes | Adam Mertz | Claire Smith |
| Pat Caputo | Joe Henderson | Bruce Miles | Clark Spencer |
| Rene Cardenas | Jim Henneman | Scott Miller | Jordan Sprechman |
| Marc Carig | Lynn Henning | Randy Miller | Arnie Stapleton |
| Leon Carter | Manolo Hernandez-Douen | Phil Miller | Jayson Stark |
| Bill Center | Steve Herrick | Larry Millson | Alex Stern |
| Murray Chass | Mark Herrmann | Fred Mitchell | Carl Steward |
| Ronald Chimelis | Jon Heyman | Kevin Modesti | Joe Stiglich |
| Joe Christensen | Brian Heyman | Terence Moore | Larry Stone |
| Jay Cohen | John Hickey | Aurelio Moreno | Paul Sullivan |
| Lowell Cohn | Hirozaku Higuchi | Jon Morosi | T.R. Sullivan |
| Bob Cohn | Steve Hirdt | Rick Morrissey | Tara Sullivan |
| Gene Collier | Peter Hirdt | Chuck Murr | Gaku Tashiro |
| Roberto Colon | Thomas Hirdt | Carrie Muskat | Rick Telander |
| Dan Connolly | Kenneth Hirdt | Gene Myers | Chris Thorn |
| Ron Cook | Bob Hohler | Katsushi Nagao | Tom Timmermann |
| Kevin Cooney | Alan Hoskins | Marc Narducci | John Tomase |
| Brian Costa | Garry D. Howard | Lavelle Neal | Marc Topkin |
| Brian Costello | Paul Hoynes | Paul Newberry | Douglas Tucker |
| Greg Cote | Rick Hummel | Ross Newhan | Howard Ulman |
| Joe Cowley | Michael Hunt | Mark Newman | Mike Vaccaro |
| Tim Cowlishaw | Bob Hunter | Robert Nightengale | Dave Van Dyck |
| Jerry Crasnick | Junko Ichimura | Masayoshi Niwa | Daryl Van Schouwen |
| Glen Crevier | Mike Imrem | John Niyo | Juan Vene |
| Jack Curry | Jim Ingraham | Eric Nunez | Tom Verducci |
| Guy Curtright | Jeff Jacobs | David O'Brien | Constantino Viloria |
| Timothy Dahlberg | Jay Jaffe | Sheldon Ocker | Mike Waldner |
| Tom D'Angelo | Bruce Jenkins | Jack O'Connell | Charley Walters |
| Dave Daniel | Chad Jennings | Ian O'Connor | Carroll Walton |
| Paul Daugherty | Joey Johnston | Charles Odum | Bob Waterman |
| Shi Davidi | Richard Justice | Hideki Okuda | Kirk Wessler |
| Ken Davidoff | Dick Kaegel | Drew Olson | Mark Whicker |
| Art Davidson | Christina Kahrl | Jesus Ortiz | Paul White |
| Felix DeJesus | Tim Kawakami | Jorge Ortiz | David Wilhelm |
| Chris DeLuca | Joe Kay | Joe Ostermeier | George Willis |
| Tony DeMarco | Tom Keegan | Jill Painter | Bernie Wilson |
| Steve Dilbeck | Peter Kerasotis | Robert Parent | Jeff Wilson |
| Ryan Divish | Fred Kerber | Robert Parker | Bill Windler |
| Mike Dodd | Kevin Kernan | Gregg Patton | Steve Wine |
| Josh Dubow | Ann Killion | Dave Perkins | Hank Winnicki |
| Robert Duff | George King | John Perrotto | Tom Withers |
| Bob Dutton | Mark Kiszla | Mike Peticca | Gordon Wittenmyer |
| Chuck Dybdal | Hideo Kizaki | Ed Petruska | Robert Wojnowski |
| Jorge Ebro | Bob Klapisch | Bill Plunkett | Gregg Wong |
| Gordon Edes | Chuck Klonke | Terry Pluto | Akiko Yamawaki |
| Bob Elliott | Michael Knisley | George Pohly | Masashi Yamazaki |
| Chris Elsberry | Nobuyuki Kobayashi | Steve Politi | Mark Zuckerman |
| John Erardi | Keizo Konishi | Monte Poole | |
| Jack Etkin | Steve Kornacki | Steven Popper | |
| Ryan Fagan | Dejan Kovacevic | Joe Posnanski |