Below is a breakdown of the 30 individual ballots, submitted by two writers representing each city in the American League. For more information on the voting, see our Voting FAQ.
| Name | Affiliation | Chapter | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th | 6th | 7th | 8th | 9th | 10th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gabe Lacques | USA Today | BAL | Alvarez | Caminero | Vargas | Witt Jr. | Rice | Arozarena | McGonigle | Rafaela | Alonso | Schlittler |
| Tim Kurkjian | ESPN | BAL | Alvarez | Caminero | Rice | Schlittler | Vargas | Witt Jr. | Abreu | Contreras | Alonso | McGonigle |
| Tim Healey | Boston Globe | BOS | Alvarez | Caminero | Schlittler | Alonso | Rice | Witt Jr. | Contreras | Vargas | Arozarena | McGonigle |
| Sean McAdam | MassLive.com | BOS | Alvarez | Caminero | Witt Jr. | Contreras | Schlittler | Vargas | Alonso | Rice | Arozarena | McGonigle |
| James Fegan | Chicago Sun-Times | CHI | Alvarez | Caminero | Witt Jr. | McGonigle | Schlittler | Arozarena | Vargas | Messick | Cease | Alonso |
| LaMond Pope | Chicago Tribune | CHI | Alvarez | Caminero | Witt Jr. | Schlittler | McGonigle | Contreras | Vargas | Rice | Alonso | Arozarena |
| Paul Hoynes | Cleveland.com/The Plain Dealer | CLE | Alvarez | Caminero | Vargas | Alonso | Abreu | Murakami | Kwan | Rice | Witt Jr. | McGonigle |
| Tim Stebbins | MLB.com | CLE | Alvarez | Caminero | Witt Jr. | Schlittler | Rice | McGonigle | Alonso | Arozarena | Contreras | Vargas |
| Jason Beck | MLB.com | DET | Alvarez | Caminero | Vargas | Alonso | Arozarena | McGonigle | Schlittler | Witt Jr. | Contreras | Messick |
| Cody Stavenhagen | The Athletic | DET | Alvarez | Caminero | Schlittler | Witt Jr. | McGonigle | Vargas | Arozarena | Alonso | Abreu | Rice |
| Kristie Rieken | The Associated Press | HOU | Alvarez | Caminero | Witt Jr. | McGonigle | Schlittler | Alonso | Rice | Vargas | Cease | Arozarena |
| MoiseKapenda Bower | Field Level Media | HOU | Alvarez | Caminero | Schlittler | McGonigle | Witt Jr. | Vargas | Alonso | Arozarena | Rice | Contreras |
| Vahe Gregorian | The Kansas City Star | KC | Alvarez | Caminero | Witt Jr. | Schlittler | Alonso | Rice | Contreras | Arozarena | Vargas | McGonigle |
| Dave Skretta | The Associated Press | KC | Alvarez | Schlittler | Caminero | McGonigle | Witt Jr. | Arozarena | Cease | Vargas | Abreu | Paredes |
| Sam Blum | The Athletic | LA | Alvarez | Caminero | Vargas | Witt Jr. | Schlittler | Alonso | McGonigle | Contreras | Messick | Durán |
| Jeff Fletcher | Orange County Register | LA | Alvarez | Caminero | Schlittler | Contreras | Alonso | Rice | Arozarena | Vargas | Messick | Witt Jr. |
| Bobby Nightengale | Minnesota Star Tribune | MIN | Alvarez | Caminero | Schlittler | Vargas | Alonso | Contreras | Arozarena | Rice | McGonigle | Witt Jr. |
| Dan Hayes | The Athletic | MIN | Alvarez | Caminero | Schlittler | Witt Jr. | Arozarena | Vargas | McGonigle | Contreras | Rice | Smith |
| Bob Klapisch | Star-Ledger/NJ.com | NY | Alvarez | Caminero | Schlittler | Alonso | Rice | Contreras | Witt Jr. | Vargas | Rasmussen | Arozarena |
| David Lennon | NY Newsday | NY | Alvarez | Caminero | Alonso | Schlittler | Contreras | Rice | Vargas | Witt Jr. | Arozarena | Rasmussen |
| Adam Jude | The Seattle Times | SEA | Alvarez | Caminero | Witt Jr. | McGonigle | Dingler | Arozarena | Alonso | Rice | Vargas | Rafaela |
| Daniel Kramer | MLB.com | SEA | Alvarez | Caminero | Alonso | Vargas | Rice | Witt Jr. | Schlittler | Arozarena | Contreras | McGonigle |
| Eno Sarris | The Athletic | SF/ATH | Alvarez | Witt Jr. | Caminero | Schlittler | McGonigle | Alonso | Vargas | Arozarena | Messick | Cease |
| Martín Gallegos | MLB.com | SF/ATH | Alvarez | Caminero | Witt Jr. | Schlittler | Vargas | Alonso | Arozarena | McGonigle | Cease | Dingler |
| Marc Topkin | Tampa Bay Times | TB | Alvarez | Caminero | Witt Jr. | Alonso | Arozarena | Vargas | Schlittler | Abreu | McGonigle | Kwan |
| Adam Berry | MLB.com | TB | Alvarez | Caminero | Schlittler | Witt Jr. | Alonso | Arozarena | McGonigle | Vargas | Rice | Contreras |
| Kennedi Landry | MLB.com | TEX | Alvarez | Caminero | Witt Jr. | Schlittler | McGonigle | Arozarena | Alonso | Cease | Vargas | Paredes |
| Evan Grant | Dallas Morning News | TEX | Alvarez | Caminero | Rice | Contreras | Witt Jr. | Alonso | Schlittler | Vargas | Durán | Arozarena |
| Mike Wilner | Toronto Star | TOR | Alvarez | Caminero | Witt Jr. | Alonso | McGonigle | Schlittler | Rice | Cease | Arozarena | Smith |
| Mitch Bannon | The Athletic | TOR | Alvarez | Witt Jr. | Caminero | Alonso | Schlittler | McGonigle | Arozarena | Cease | Vargas | Rice |